🚗 🚙 Turn your trusty old car into trustworthy journalism Learn more

Immigration reform has foes on both sides

Marketplace Staff May 14, 2007
HTML EMBED:
COPY

Immigration reform has foes on both sides

Marketplace Staff May 14, 2007
HTML EMBED:
COPY

KAI RYSSDAL: The Senate’s working on immigration reform this week. Bipartisan immigration reform, that is. A bill did pass last year but most Republicans didn’t like it much. The package currently in the works puts border security first. Then a high-tech ID system for undocumented workers would kick win. Only after that might millions of illegal immigrants get a chance at legal status.

Once Congress went to the Democrats, speculation was it’d be easier for a deal to get done. But commentator Jeff Birnbaum says opposition to a key vote on Wednesday might come from a surprising source.


JEFF BIRNBAUM: The conventional wisdom is that, after years of frustration on the issue, President Bush could well get a new immigration law.

But for that, Bush will have to partner with a broad swath of the Democrats-in-charge on Capitol Hill.

The reason: Most of his fellow Republicans are none too keen about giving foreign workers the chance to become citizens just because they’ve lived here for a while. And that provision would be the heart of any comprehensive solution.

It turns out, though, that Democrats aren’t all that eager to embrace the change. In fact, a large number of Democrats are likely to resist.

And here’s why. Labor unions, a fundamental constituency of the Democratic Party, are deeply divided on the topic.

Luckily for Bush, two of the nation’s largest and most influential unions — the Service Employees International Union and Unite Here, the hotel and sewing workers’ union — are eager to include a program that would allow foreigners to work temporarily in this country.

They envision eventual citizenship, too — a plan similar to one that Bush has advanced in the past. These unions, which tend to represent lower-paid workers, foresee a lot of future members in that expanding labor pool.

But almost every other union, including the big union federation, the AFL -CIO, does not like that proposal at all.

In fact, they oppose a so-called guest-worker program, worrying that the additional foreign workers would take away Americans’ jobs, including those their members now hold.

They intend to fight such a program with all the strength they have. That leaves Democratic lawmakers with a difficult choice. Some will go with Bush, but others will go with the majority of unions.

And that could well prevent the president from winning on immigration this year.

RYSSDAL: Jeff Birnbaum is a columnist for The Washington Post.

There’s a lot happening in the world.  Through it all, Marketplace is here for you. 

You rely on Marketplace to break down the world’s events and tell you how it affects you in a fact-based, approachable way. We rely on your financial support to keep making that possible. 

Your donation today powers the independent journalism that you rely on. For just $5/month, you can help sustain Marketplace so we can keep reporting on the things that matter to you.