1

Time to consolidate

Question: Having had three job changes, my investments are in three locations, with a fourth about to start. I have a Roth with Merrill Lynch, 401(k) with Vanguard and 401(k) with Principal Financial Group. Is it a benefit to combine all investments into one account? I need to educate myself on my money. Most that I have invested is in aggressive funds. I am 47 and getting older each day!! Jeff, Tulsa, OK

Answer: Your experience is common. People change jobs over time and one consequence is they end up with a string of retirement savings plans from different financial firms and a bunch of mutual fund investments. I think there are genuine benefits to consolidating the accounts. Before doing anything, I spend some time going over what you have and where you want to be invested. And you're still young!

(As an aside, I've been to Tulsa several times. I’ve always enjoyed my trips -- especially walking through the gardens at the Philbrook Museum of Art, wandering around the western art collection at the Gilcrease Museum and visiting the University of Tulsa.)

I am concerned that you have so much of your retirement funds in the more aggressive fund categories. The fundamental insight of finance is that you create the possibility of earning a higher return by taking greater risk. But there is no guarantee, even with a long-term horizon, that you'll make that higher return. You could lose out. You want a well-diversified portfolio.

For instance, stocks are riskier than bonds since equities represent the uncertain rewards for entrepreneurship, while bonds are long-term contracts that spell out when borrowers must make principal and interest payments. Despite the hours people spend agonizing over mutual funds and worrying over the market's every twist, asset allocation is the main determinant of your portfolio's performance. Asset allocation is a fancy way of saying that how you divide your money among the investment options available to you.

One way to figure out what kind of portfolio you should have is to think about your career and your goals. The more secure your income from work, the more risk you can afford to take with your portfolio -- and vice versa. You also want to come up with a sense of what would it take for you to have a minimally comfortable standard of living in retirement. You hope to do better, of course. But a minimal benchmark allows you to better match your investments with your retirement goals.

A good short book on how to invest over a lifetime is The Random Walk Guide to Investing by Burton Malkiel. It deals well with asset allocation, diversification, risk and return. Malkiel is an advocate for keeping it simple -- always good advice.

  

 

I would also look at in Risk Less and Prosper: Your Guide to Safer Investing by Zvi Bodie and Rachelle Taqqu.

The two authors make a strong case for investing with a conservative eye on downside risk rather than upside gain. I like the way they match up money with career and lifestyle.

Between those two works, you could develop a good idea about what kind of portfolio you want. And then consolidate your 401(k)s into that portfolio.

About the author

Chris Farrell is the economics editor of Marketplace Money.
JackSmithy's picture
JackSmithy - Mar 20, 2012

Also, to the extent that Jeff was asking about consolidating his accounts at Merrill Lynch, Vanguard and Principal Financial Group into one retirement account at a single institution, I (a non-finance professional, but an avid "Getting Personal" reader ;-) think that diversification is good.

I used to hear that the extra administrative costs outweighed the risk that you would lose all of your money, especially if you kept your money at a large institution. Of course, that was before the downfall of Lehman Brothers and the government had to bail out numerous large institutions.

While your retirement savings may be insured by the FDIC (depending on where you keep it), you do not want to risk having to wait while the process winds through the legal system if you plan on living on that savings in retirement.

For me, the minimal extra administrative hassle of having to keep track of separate accounts at separate institutions (I keep our retirement savings at Vanguard, Fidelity, and Citibank) give me the peace of mind in knowing that even if one or two of the three institutions goes down, I will at least have a third of my retirement savings available to keep me going. (If all three go down, then we're all in a lot of trouble.)

Just my two cents, and I would be eager to hear what others are doing with their money.