2

Socially responsible Investing

Question: I'd like to invest in a green mutual fund, one that develops wind and solar energies, electric cars etc. I've been looking at Winslow green growth. Any thoughts or suggestions? Kate, Sheridan, WY

Answer: I looked up the Winslow Green Growth fund on the www.morningstar.com website. As of writing this column, the fund's year-to-date return was down -22.50%. Its one-year return is -5.60% and its 5-year return annualized is 17.73%. Its net expense ratio is 1.45%, which is on the high side. (According to Morningstar fees on green funds range between 1.25% and 1.98%.)

I typically prefer index funds that cover a range of industries and charge low fees, and there are a number of "green" index funds. Once you've created a broadly diversified portfolio and you then want to place a bet on a sector or a fund or a company with a small percentage of your portfolio, well, by all means go ahead--have some fun. If you're interested in doing more research about socially responsible investing two good websites are www.socialinvest.org and www.socialfunds.com.

The biggest rap against the movement is the belief that marrying personal values to an investment portfolio cuts into returns. In other words, doing good and making money don't mix. I don't agree. A number of studies suggest there's little difference between pooling money to make money and pooling money to make money and express values. This came home to me in a series of papers by Meir Statman, a finance economist at Santa Clara University. Among his conclusions, the risk-adjusted return on socially conscious index funds is roughly comparable to the Standard & Poor's 500 index and the performance of actively managed socially responsible mutual funds is about equal to their conventional mutual fund peers. (You can read his papers on the subject at www.scu.edu/business/finance/research/sristatman.cfm.)

One note of caution: Socially responsible funds tend to have high fees that cut into returns. So while it always pays to shop around it's especially true in this industry.

About the author

Chris Farrell is the economics editor of Marketplace Money.
Ron Robins's picture
Ron Robins - May 1, 2008

Good to see your comment on green funds and socially responsible investing.

I've been following socially responsible investing for around forty years. Your readers interested in this subject might find my website helpful. It's unique in that it covers the latest global news and research in this area. It's at http://investingforthesoul.com/

Best wishes, Ron Robins

Ted's picture
Ted - May 1, 2008

"Green" investing: Good idea. Bad strategy.

Practice your values as the motto says: "Think globally *act* locally."

Acting globally, while nice, will not have as much effect. Make your money and then vote your values with how you spend your money.

If you must invest green, then I suggest a slight tilt of 5% to 10% of your total portfolio.