Chasing the mythical 8% return

Tess Vigeland: So basically what we're saying is, you can't count on anything when it comes to investing. And that applies even to some of the most common conventional wisdom out there.

Commentator Chris Farrell wants you to think about one number in particular.


Chris Farrell: We've all heard some version of the 8-percent line: If you save $100 a month at 8 percent over the next 40 years, you'll be worth about $1.4 million.

But there are a few problems with that calculation.

For one thing, the 8-percent number doesn't take inflation into account. Inflation simply means a dollar today is worth less tomorrow. So, let's say inflation runs around 2.5 percent -- a reasonable guesstimate. After taking inflation into account, your 8-percent return is really 5.5 percent. Instead of being a millionaire, you'll be worth several hundred thousand dollars. Not bad, but not a million bucks either. And who's getting an 8-percent return on their money these days anyway?

Not the diversified investor, that's for sure. Diversification means that while you've got some risky investments in there that might get you 8 percent, you've got some safe stuff, too. And the safe stuff will lower your potential return.

Finally, there's the timing. Investment plans that tout high yields are based on an average return over time. You're heard the one about the statistician who drowns in eight feet of water while crossing a river. His last words: "But it's only three feet deep on average!"

Investors run the same risk. You could live your whole life getting a great return, and then, just as you're about to retire, the market collapses, wiping out all of your gains out completely. That's what happened to a whole generation of investors when Lehman Brothers collapsed in 2008. And it could happen to you, too.

So don't believe the 8-percent lie. Instead, save your money. Sure, buy some risky stocks. But sock the rest away in safe places, like Treasury bills and bank accounts protected by the FDIC. This way your money will grow a little more than inflation. And while you won't make an 8-percent return, you will have the peace of mind of knowing your money will be there when you need it -- no matter what happens to the market.


Vigeland: Chris Farrell is the economics editor for Marketplace.

About the author

Chris Farrell is the economics editor of Marketplace Money.

Comments

I agree to American Public Media's Terms and Conditions.
With Generous Support From...