24

Will Williams' firing affect fundraising?

Juan Williams

To view this content, Javascript must be enabled and Adobe Flash Player must be installed.

Get Adobe Flash player

TEXT OF STORY

Kai Ryssdal: This next story comes with a disclaimer of sorts. You hear me make it every day. Marketplace is produced by American Public Media, not NPR. So we approach the Juan Williams story with no inside information. The longtime NPR news analyst was fired Wednesday night for violating NPR's ethics policies. For public radio stations, the timing and the ensuing backlash is less than ideal. A lot of them, as you may have been hearing on your station, are in the middle of their pledge drives.

Marketplace's Janet Babin reports.


Janet Babin: Juan Williams clarified his controversial remarks on "Good Morning America."

JUAN WILLIAMS: If I'm at the gate at an airport and I see people who are in Muslim garb, who are first and foremost identifying themselves as Muslims, in the aftermath of 9/11, I am taken aback, I have a moment of fear.

But many Muslim groups were outraged by the comments, and NPR took swift action to terminate Williams. That controversy led to another one: People upset by the firing threatened to withhold public radio contributions. And this is fall fundraising week.

In Austin, KUT'S general manager Stewart Vanderwilt says he's heard from about 50 listeners.

Stewart Vanderwilt: Some are expressing concern, some are seeking more information, in a few cases canceling their support, or informing us that they will not be contributing to the station.

The complaints didn't affect KUT's fundraising. But the Williams fallout could have other consequences. Some politicians have called for cuts in NPR's federal funding. Less than 2 percent of NPRs revenue comes indirectly from federal sources. Most funding comes from member stations. But at rural stations, federal funding can account for close to 40 percent of revenue.

Andy Brimmer is at crisis management firm Joele Frank, Wilkinson Brimmer Katcher.

Andy Brimmer: You don't pick a fight with someone who has a very large bully pulpit, and Juan Williams obviously has a very large bully pulpit.

Willams has reportedly signed a deal with Fox News for a figure large enough to fund the annual budgets of many public radio stations.

I'm Janet Babin for Marketplace.

Pages

D. R. Arthur's picture
D. R. Arthur - Oct 22, 2010

Vivian Shiller knew this is fund raising week and demonstrated an unCEO like outburst. She should own up and quit so Juan Williams can be hired back. The real reason Juan was shown the door is envy on the part of some NPR staff as to the success Juan Williams earns through hard work and incredible energy.

RG Marr's picture
RG Marr - Oct 22, 2010

NPR has sunk to a very deep low with the dismissal of Juan Williams and the process in which it was delivered with personal, demeaning slanders. What about free speech and the 1st amendment? Vivian Schiller and Nina Tottenberg should be fired immediately if NPR wants a whiff of credibility and future donors other than George Sorros. If I were Juan, I would not want this job back, but he deserves a $20000000,00 settlement for this intentional slander by Schiller.

Terry Freeman's picture
Terry Freeman - Oct 22, 2010

Why doesn't Juan Williams understand the difference between a "journalist" and "commentator"? He apparently thinks that journalists don't have to limit their own opinions to maintain their appearance of objectivity. Journalists are NOT found on Foxs News -- Heck, NEWS is not found on Fox News.

Verne Powell's picture
Verne Powell - Oct 22, 2010

I was very disappointed in the decision by NPR to fire Juan Williams. If cool heads like Juan are not allowed to even discuss the conflicts between western countries and Islam, then how will we find solutions? To suggest that Juan Williams is racist because of his comments is ridiculous. I suspect that his contract with Fox News had more to do with his departure than this particular incident. NPR has lost considerable credibility with this listener.

Pages