The loopholes of credit card reform

A number on a credit card


TESS VIGELAND: You've been waiting for it. I know you have. And it's finally here. The bulk of the credit card reform act passed last spring takes effect on Monday. It lays down rules on everything from interest rates to fees, to how far industry representatives have to stay away from college campuses. But for everyone who's thinking it's safe to whip out that plastic, hold on there, shopper. Where there's a rule, there's a loophole.

We asked Marketplace's Stacey Vanek-Smith to give us a roundup.

Stacey Vanek-Smith: Some of the biggest reforms in the Card Act deal with interest rates. Card companies make about two-thirds of their money from interest rate payments. Not hard to see why. Most cards can raise your interest rate at any time, for any reason, to almost any amount. But the CARD Act crackdown is coming.

["Dragnet" theme music]

Card companies won't be able to raise your interest rate for the first year you have the card. And once they can, they have to give you 45-days notice and that new interest rate can only be applied to new charges. Your old balance stays with your old rate.

Of course, for every rule, there is a loophole.

["Pink Panther" theme music]

Like if you're late on a payment.

Bill Hardekopf is the CEO of LowCards.com.

Bill Hardekopf: If you're 60 days late on your payments, your interest rate can be hiked immediately.

And that higher penalty rate applies to what you already owe, as well as new charges.

Another loophole? The introductory rate. These cards come with special introductory offers, like zero-percent interest. The offer expires and your rate shoots up; no 45-day notice. And beware the discount rate offer, says Heather McGhee of consumer advocacy group Demos.

Heather McGhee: Credit card companies are offering you a card at the penalty rate, but saying that they're going to give you a discount rate, of a more reasonable rate, until you pay late -- so that the original rate is the penalty rate, the discount rate is the more reasonable rate.

Confused? Yeah, that's kind of the point. Here's how it works: Say you sign up for a card that has an interest rate of 30 percent, but the card company offers you a special discount rate of 15 percent. So you pay 15 percent until the card company decides the discount is over and bumps you to the 30 percent rate. That 45-day warning? Doesn't apply, because they're not technically raising the interest rate on the card; they're just taking away your discount.

Then there is the loopholes of all loopholes: the variable rate card, says Josh Frank with the Center for Responsible Lending.

Josh Frank: You're getting a card now. If it's a variable-rate card -- which 95 percent of them are -- expect your rate will go up.

Variable rates are cards whose interest rates are tied to another interest rate, usually the prime rate. When that rate moves up or down, the card's interest rate moves with it. Again, no notice necessary. And since interest rates are so low right now, if you get a variable rate card, it's basically got nowhere to go but up.

Of course, interest rates are only half the story. Fees bring in $20 billion a year for card companies. The most notorious? The over-the-limit fee. Instead of denying your card, when you reach your limit, your card company approves the charge and slaps you with a fee for the privilege.

Under the CARD Act, your card will be denied if you try to go over your limit -- unless you specially request overdraft protection. But the fee remains, says Josh Frank, with the Center for Responsible Lending.

Frank: Instead of charging an overdraft fee, you in fact reject the charges, and then, you charge them a fee for being rejected when they try and go over their credit limit.

["Pomp and Circumstance"]

College... It's where your credit card education begins. Usually with a free t-shirt and a line of credit you can't afford. The CARD Act bans card companies from campuses and outlaws those freebies. Also, students can't get a card unless they prove they can afford the payments or have an adult co-sign.

So, you can send junior off to college without worrying about racking up huge credit card bills, right? Wrong, says Robert Manning, author of "Credit Card Nation." He says card companies can still get to your kid by e-mail and direct mail. As far as making students prove they can afford a card? There's a loophole for that, too.

Robert Manning: If a credit card company offered them a $300 line of credit, a year later, what's to stop them from raising the line of credit to $1,500?

Bottom line: The CARD Act does crack down on some of the industry's biggest money-making traps.

["Dragnet" theme music]

But, you still need to read the terms and conditions. That's the encyclopedia that now accompanies your card. And you should probably read your statements really carefully. Oh, and did I mention that if you want them on paper? There's a fee for that.

I'm Stacey Vanek-Smith for Marketplace Money.

How credit card companies can still get you.


RULE: Interest rates
You have to be given 45 days notice before your interest rate can be raised. Your rate cannot be raised because you haven't paid another bill on time. Also, new rate hikes can only be applied to future balances, not existing balances. Interest rates cannot be increased in the first year you own a card.

The interest rate rules do not apply to variable-rate credit cards, which now make up 95 percent of what the credit card industry offers. Variable-rate cards are supposed to be pegged to the "prime rate," but there are exceptions:

1. The prime rate currently is extremely low, and it will only go up from here.

2. Issuers have cards with high initial rates, but customers will always pay a discount rate (e.g., the initial rate is 29 percent, but you pay a special discount rate of 11 percent). As soon as you miss a payment (or pay another bill late) the "initial rate" on your card kicks in. Because it's not technically a rate bump, the card issuer doesn't have to give you notice.

3. Card issuers can offer introductory rates with an expiration date, so read the fine print.

RULE: Opting in
Credit card companies cannot charge you fees for going over your limit, unless you sign up for an over-limit program. However, they may deny you a card.

1. Card companies will charge a fee if you hit your limit. So your card will be shut off until you pay a "bounced-card" fee.

2. Card companies may try to persuade you to opt in, saying the government is trying to take your freedoms away.

3. If your payment is more than 60 days late, penalty fees will apply.

RULE: Fee caps
A credit-card fee cannot exceed 25 percent of the card's credit limit.

1. This rule applies to "fee harvester" cards -- mostly subprime cards whose fees were often 90 percent of the credit limit. These cards have simply jacked up their interest rates as high as 80 percent.

2. The 25 percent limit applies only to the first year of card ownership.

3. Many fees are being relabeled as "penalties" and "transaction charges" (the 25 percent fee does not apply to "penalties").

RULE: If you make more than a minimum payment, your money goes to the balance with the highest interest rate (often a cash-advance rate).

1. This rule only applies if you pay more than the minimum due.

2. It does not apply to certain cards with things like "deferred interest" plans.

RULE: Student Restrictions
Card issuers cannot give a card to a minor without either a guardian's permission or proof that the student can pay. They cannot give merchandise away to students signing up for cards or set up within 1000 feet of a campus.

Card companies are increasing mail solicitations, online offers, and rewards programs to lure student card users.

Featured in: Marketplace Money

About the author

Stacey Vanek Smith is a senior reporter for Marketplace, where she covers banking, consumer finance, housing and advertising.
Log in to post9 Comments

My paper bill had one amount, but the ebill had a different amount. Seems like that Credit Card company is telling my bank the balance on the day requested, not on the statement balance.
Interesting new way to get a few more dollars and shorten the grace period.

I thought I heard it said that fees for inactive cards were part of the credit card companies response to the act. I can find no mention of them when I search. Is this true - that fees will be charged for inactive cards?

I never carry a balance on a credit card, but I have a gazillion cards with retail stores because I open an account every time someone offers me a discount off my purchase. I have open accounts I don't even know about. Do I have to be concerned that suddenly I am going to be charged fees for insufficient usage? If so, can I get a list of all the cards I have open without paying to get a credit report?

In a question and answer segment after the story, someone mentioned getting a credit card bill after having given her social security number to someone at the airport who offered her a deal. And you said that when someone asks you for your social security number "even at the doctor's office" you should ask if it's for credit card purposes. Well, what I've heard about protecting oneself from identity theft says NEVER give out your social security number without good reason. I'll give it to my employer and my bank, and a few other people. And I believe that the information on privacy they give out at doctor's offices says they do not have the right to ask for your social security number. The last time a doctor's secretary insisted on having my SS #, I wrote 123456789 and she accepted that. Now that's my number, but you're welcome to use 234etc or a handy combination of your address and phone number. In any case, DO NOT give your doctor your SS#, they don't need it and have no right to that information.

So much about credit cards-thx. What about the car dealers luring ppl in by sending a "key" to a car, and giving a reward to everyone who comes in. I wanted that $5.00 Wal*Mart card (it was in the fine print) for gasoline. They were sure I could afford a car, I knew I could not. They spent over an hour hounding me trying to convince me, even found a bank that would loan to me. My income is less thatn 900.00 per month, come one!!

(Dyer is so NOT a city lol)
As for credit card info NOT being taught in High schools, my former high school students say it is, sort of. My daugher (20, attending Univ. of Tenn. at Martin as a Mathematics major) has the opinion that credit cards are EVIL and she never wants one unless it becomes absolutely necessary (for business travel to reserve a room, for instance). My son (19, attending Austin Peay State U. in Clarksville, TN as a psych major but is in reality an undetermined major because I am confident he will change) remembers very litte about it except "it was part of Economics Class." Economics IS a required course, and they also cover checking accts vs saving accts, etc. I just wanted you to know that Gibson County High School is touching on the subject, and... a word to the WISE is apparently sufficient - (girls do mature more quickly?) - although I don't wish to call my son unwise!

I still have not heard anyone talk about "credit" without credit cards? Since the only way any "credit" can be reported on one's credit report is by the vendor paying the companies to put it on - but everyone is talking about going back to cash how is that going to work? For example, my biggest payment is my rent which is with a private landlord who does not pay to report to the credit companies (as this is his only rental that makes sense). But since he does not there is not anyway to get the positive report of my payments onto my credit report - ditto all the "cash" payments. So what now - particularly for people trying to rebuild their credit. The whole credit reporting industry is exactly that - only to make money for the large companies but they "control" how we all "live".

What is the max rate on a card? In NY State it used to be 29%. Do States have a right to set a max interst rat?

To call these and other business practices “loopholes” frames them as oversights that more judicious legislation would have closed. But of course they are not oversights. Credit card companies could make a nice profit by charging reasonable interest rates and engaging in honest business practices. But without predatory business practices they would not make obscene profits, like Wall Street investment “banks”, private equity, mutual funds, etc. for doing almost nothing. Those business practices enable them to contribute huge amounts of money to the people we elect who then create the “loopholes” in the legislation then call it “reform”. Such legislation impedes recover from the Great Recession. This is known as kleptocratic government.

With Generous Support From...