6

Injured veterans fight for benefits

Dell and Annette McLeod outside of the VA in Columbia, S.C.

To view this content, Javascript must be enabled and Adobe Flash Player must be installed.

Get Adobe Flash player

TEXT OF STORY

Bob Moon: More than seven years into the war in Afghanistan, reinforcements are on the way. Another 17,000 troops are being sent in -- as Commander-in-Chief Obama explains it -- to "stabilize a deteriorating situation."

Already, beyond the cost in lives and money, there are monumental funding issues, caring for the severely wounded from both Iraq and Afghanistan. Not to mention: systemic problems within the military and the Veterans Administration, which can sometimes prevent disabled vets from collecting the benefits they're owed.

As Marketplace's Jeff Tyler reports, wounded soldiers are often finding they've traded one battlefield for another.


JEFF TYLER: Forty-two-year-old Dell McLeod has trouble with his memory. But he knows precisely how long he was in the military.

DELL MCLEOD: I pulled three years, ten months and three days of regular army.

In 2005, he was badly hurt in Kuwait. The driver of his supply truck didn't secure the cargo door
and it came crashing down on Dell.

MCLEOD: I was airborne. I fell. And I was like a pretzel when I hit the ground. I was unconscious. I sustained a brain injury. Back injury. Goin' cripple in my right leg.

While he was recovering at Walter Reed army hospital, his wife Annette spent two years battling the army over Dell's disability benefits. During lunch at a BBQ restaurant in Columbia, South Carolina, Annette says the army dragged its feet when it came to diagnosing Dell's brain injury, a delay she believes cost them tens of thousands of dollars.

ANNETTE MCLEOD: Because he did not get a traumatic brain injury diagnosis in 90 days, he did not qualify for the Traumatic Servicemen's Group Life Insurance -- that was up to a $100,000.

Some veterans advocates say the military has been systematically short-changing service members on disability benefits.

Soldiers given a military disability rating below 30 percent get a one-time severance payment instead of life-long medical benefits for the whole family.

Kerry Baker -- with the Disabled American Veterans -- says the army cherry-picks lesser injuries when applying its disability standards. In military-speak, disabilities are referred to as "unfitting conditions." That's any injury that prevents soldiers from performing their duties.

KERRY BAKER: The military may choose the ankle injury as the unfitting condition and give them ten percent. And then may determine that the traumatic brain injury, and the back injury, and the shell fragment wounds are not unfitting. And therefore they don't get a disability rating for those particular disabilities at all. And we see that a lot.

Why would the military do that?

BAKER: We have been of the opinion that it's monetarily based. You know, it's an effort to save money.

GEN. KEITH MEURLIN: Absolutely not.

That's Major General Keith Meurlin, acting director of the Transition Policy and Care Coordination Office at the Defense Department.

Meurlin: There has never been a reference to cut to money off. It's, how do we make sure the veterans who have served and been injured are treated fairly and compensated fairly for what they've sacrificed.

But Meurlin acknowledges some short-comings with the process.

Meurlin: I think there's a universal feeling that the old system that we have needs some serious modification and tweaking.

That system requires vets to have one disability evaluation while in the military. Then, once they're discharged, the evaluation process starts all over again with the Department of Veterans Affairs, the VA.

Despite repeated requests, the VA did not make someone available for an interview. The VA has been criticized for not moving quickly enough to handle the surge in new veterans. The backlog for disability claims is in the hundreds of thousands. The VA has been hiring more staff to help cope with the increased demand. But processing a disability claim remains daunting.

Paul Rieckhoff: The burden of proof is always on that veteran.

Paul Rieckhoff is executive director of Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America. He says appealing a disability claim can take years and many vets just can't afford to wait that long.

Rieckhoff: When you're trying to put food on your table and you may be working two jobs and you're dealing with an injury, veterans often take what they can get now, rather than try to fight the system over time. And often times, they end up getting less of a benefit than they probably deserve.

Once benefits are finally determined, some veterans still have trouble taking advantage of them. Especially in rural America.

Dell and Annette McLeod drive over two hours -- each way -- from their hometown in rural South Carolina to the nearest VA... in Columbia.

McLeod: Oh, a good week, it's one day a week. On a week when we can't shift all the appointments, it's two to three times a week.

There is some progress to report. The VA and the Department of Defense have partnered on a pilot program that combines the two disability evaluations into one. Major Gen. Meurlin says the new system is twice as fast and generates higher payments for disabled vets. The Pentagon will expand the program to more locations this summer.

In Columbia, S.C., I'm Jeff Tyler for Marketplace.

About the author

Jeff Tyler is a reporter for Marketplace’s Los Angeles bureau, where he reports on issues related to immigration and Latin America.
Rick Espinoza's picture
Rick Espinoza - Aug 24, 2011

HI I am 12yr seabee vet from 73 to 85 both active and reserves, this is not for me but for my daugther who just return from Afghanistan she substained an injury to her ankle while pulling her sargent out of a burning building and after recieving direct hits tearing a ligament in her foot. now she is need of an operation to repair the torn ligament the v.a. will deal with that amd the 4 mo. of rehab. but what about her income for that period of time california wont help because it's a military issue and the military (v.a.) said that they have no compensation for reservist I dont get it she was active at the time... now she know why I have dealt with my issuse on my own is there any out there or within the v.a. system that will help or explain why

Alan Britton's picture
Alan Britton - Oct 16, 2009

Iam a Viet Nam combat disabled Marine. The VA keeps chaning my claim for disabilities, VA regional office Columbia SC on an appeal, and no one will take my power of attorney to help me, I was struck in the head, impaired intelectual funtictioning, in Khe Sanh, 1968, I need some help.

Sarah Dale's picture
Sarah Dale - Jul 17, 2009

After 9 years of military service, 3 deployments, 1 war, and two serious injuries, my husband has still received no help from the National Guard nor the VA. I greatly appreciate this story, but where do we go from here? It is wonderful to bring to the public's attention the wrongs and injustices brought against our veterans, but how do we help them further?

I'd be interested in hearing a story about how veterans can help themselves get justice from the wrongs committed against them by the VA and the U.S. military. The military doesn't provide resources for veterans being ignored by the system, so who can? Someone please help all those thousands of voices that are going unheard.

philip grayson's picture
philip grayson - Apr 20, 2009

looking for sam roberts from viet nam we hit mine in pleiku 68 69.sam was from sc.e mail me at phlipns@aol.com

Thomas Goff's picture
Thomas Goff - Mar 9, 2009

Missing from this story is a 'mini-scandal' of four VA Regional Offices that were caught shredding documents from veteran's disability claims before they had been adjudicated.

It is also worthwhile to note that the backlog of pending claims has not shortened in any meaningful way, and that the average wait is still over 6 months. Add to that the fact that many veterans who are discharged for medical disability lack health care until their VA claims can be completed in their favor. I've been fighting for over 2 years to get my disability rating upgraded, and simply asking what the status is from the VA takes - in their words - several weeks. This is atrocious. If enlistees knew, they'd be working at Wal-Mart instead of defending America.

Douglas Arnold's picture
Douglas Arnold - Feb 18, 2009

I thought it was seriously disrespectful to interrupt the seriousness of the Dell McLeod's injuries with the segue, "But first, let's do the numbers..."

In my opinion, that was just awful. I pray that Dell and Annette were not listening to the broadcast.