How Juarez became murder city

Charles Bowden


Kai Ryssdal: The Mexican drug wars got rare play in American newspapers a couple of weeks ago when workers at the U.S. consulate in Ciudad Juarez were killed. Juarez is one of the most violent cities in the world, an unwelcome distinction that Charles Bowden explores in his new book. It's called "Murder City: Ciudad Juarez and the Global Economy's New Killing Fields." Bowden's spent the better part of the last 15 years covering the changes in Juarez, just south of El Paso, Texas. And when we spoke, I asked him when things began to change and why.

CHARLES BOWDEN: In December of 2006, the president of Mexico, Felipe Calderon, declared an official war against the drug cartels in Mexico, unleashed the Mexican army. Now in 2007, there were 307 murders in Juarez. In 2008, there were 1,600-plus. Last year, there were 2,600. What's happened also at the same time is the collapse of the city -- 27 percent of the houses have been abandoned, there's 116,000 abandoned houses. At least 100,000 jobs in the factories have disappeared because of the recession. Half of the adolescents in Juarez neither have a job nor attend school. What you're looking at is a kind of disintegration of a society.

RYSSDAL: You make the point in your book that Ciudad today is really a post-economy city. There's nothing there but the drug trade.

BOWDEN: Well, there's something there besides the drug trade, there are still these American-owned factories. Juarez for decades was a kind of poster child for free trade, and for border factories. It pioneered the concept starting in the late '60s. The city's growth has been based off that. What it's produced are American-owned factories that pay people less than they can work on. What's it's produced -- because it's a natural pathway for commerce connecting with U.S. transportation systems -- is one of the largest drug import industries in the world. What it's also produced is the largest human migration on earth, and it is directly triggered by the North American Free Trade Agreement passed in 1994. Now that treaty was passed to stop the migration -- that we would create wealth in Mexico. Instead we've created poverty.

RYSSDAL: Even if you accept the fact that part of what's happening in Juarez is that Americans want cheap goods, and we signed on to the North American Free Trade Agreement. So too did the Mexico government, didn't they?

BOWDEN: Yes, but we actually put it through a U.S. Congress, and actually talked about it. There was no discussion there. It was announced to the Mexican people. It was announced by the leadership. It was announced by an oligarchy. Mexico is famous for having the most unequal income distribution in the Western hemisphere.

RYSSDAL: What's the hope down there? Is it the Americans' job to help them get what we have?

BOWDEN: I mean, the hope is it's always darkest before the dawn. But what I think is the United States has a responsibility not to make things worse. The United States is never going to be secure by living next to a country that's starving to death. Do you think you can maintain your house in your neighborhood, and have people starving to death next door? Well, you can't.

RYSSDAL: What is it that makes you keep going down there?

BOWDEN: I think it's a window in the future. Juarez is portrayed by people as a modern city, and in many ways it is. You can go over there, and there's a Radisson and an Applebee's. But in fact as the years go by, everything is going backwards there. It's more violent. Wages and real pesos and real dollars decline. More and more people come to the city as a rural economy collapses. If you go to Juarez, you can see everything that is happening. Now, this is happening around the world. But Juarez is convenient. You just walk across the bridge, and it slaps you in the face.

RYSSDAL: Charles Bowden. His most recent book is called "Murder City" about Ciudad Juarez. Mr. Bowden, thanks a lot for your time.

BOWDEN: Well, thank you.

Log in to post16 Comments


I feel bad that these people that live in that city have to go out with fear.I have Family in that city calling that they would never set foot in the streets. The streets are empty at night, don't go out past 9. I use to go there for the good food and everything. now i will never set foot in that city ever again.

the point is that the mexico government is controlled by the cartels

what do the drug cartels have to do with the disappearance of so many maquiladora female workers?
2 very different issues... however when speaking about murders people only focus on the cartels.

Mexico doesnt have a drug problem, in fact it is the dependency of drugs that the US has that is the problem!

andyg - Killing Pablo was written by Mark Bowden, author of Black Hawk Down. Charles Bowden is a different author. But yes, both books are very compelling and show that the situation and ultimate solution(s) are complicated.

i was born in Juarez, and raised in El Paso. The truth is that the U.S. gov. is always working behind the scenes! The same way the war on drugs demolished cities in southern California - they want to do the same in Juarez. they want my people to kill themselves and then go back and rebuild as they please! lets stop fooling ourselves people!

I agree with the fact that corruption is a serious problem down here in Mexico, it is a tremendous problem that in all likelihood touches base with people in the Goverment. Alas the corruption is also present in the CBP department of the border entry points, there's been countless documented cases of officers arrested for facilitating shipments of drugs from MX to USA. So the corruption goes both ways, there's a lot of corruption in both the US and MX, the only difference is that it's more notorious down here.

Enjoyed hearing the gent from Alaska say that Bowden has it right on. Here in El Paso it strikes me that the opposite is true on both accounts. The alternative to having American maquilas in Juarez is not having any manufacturing of anything, no jobs and no growth. Yes, manufacturing hurts farming, but, as Bowden rightly points out, Mexico's unfair economic system and its corruption are the main issues behind Juarez's collapse. Don't be blinded by American money. If it wasn't drugs and guns it would something else. As long as there is no rule of law and a legitimate fear among citizens of just who the authorities are really working for there will be no solution. The corruption must stop first, and that's not something the U.S. could ever solve.

I don't think the U.S should be at blamed for Juarez killings, it's should the Mexican goverment for beign corrupt


With Generous Support From...