3

Silent hybrid cars to get a soundtrack

Ford gasoline-powered, electric, hybrid and plug-in hybrid vehicles come off the line at the Michigan Assembly Plant on November 8, 2012 in Wayne, Michigan.

To view this content, Javascript must be enabled and Adobe Flash Player must be installed.

Get Adobe Flash player

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration wants to pass a new rule that would require some cars to make more noise, specifically those silent electric and hybrid vehicles.

Jamie Kitman, the New York bureau chief of Automobile magazine, remembers test driving the very first Tesla, an electric sports car, when he saw two guys about to cross the road in front of him.

"I was thinking: 'God these people are pretending they don't even hear me coming,' and sure enough right as I was about to run them over, they turned with a start and ran," says Kitman.

That problem is expected to grow as more electric cars hit the road. The new rule is in a public comment period. It would require automakers to add some kind of sound that the cars emit at low speeds, loud enough for bicyclists and pedestrians to hear. Kitman says the sound could be customizable.

"There's no reason your car couldn't sound like Rush Limbaugh or Rachel Maddow or Led Zeppelin," he says.

Most likely, the car companies will choose something that sounds like a traditional car engine. That's not too far off base from what they already do, says Michelle Krebs at Edmunds.com. She points out that many cars already have artificial mechanical sounds, added to enhance the driving experience.

"When you're driving a performance car, they can tune it to sound really gutteral or throaty," says Krebs.

But most electric and hybrid car drivers like that their cars are quiet. So expect whatever sound the car companies choose to be subtle.

About the author

Eve Troeh is a reporter on Marketplace’s Sustainability Desk, filing features and breaking stories on how sustainability issues impact business and the economy.
ThomasWilliams's picture
ThomasWilliams - May 7, 2013

I don’t think that car drivers and manufacturers should be penalized for the EV’s very faint sound emission. I think pedestrians and other cars should be responsible enough when crossing the road or driving along main roads that may have the high possibility that an EV is also driving alongside. Installing a sound device, I hope, will not increase the prices even more. I hope that it will maintain its affordability. This should be taken into consideration, and I think the public has to be educated as well with this. Otherwise, it defeats the purpose of having EV, with all the noise coming from it.
....................
Thomas Williams - http://www.carid.com

Jordan14's picture
Jordan14 - Feb 16, 2013

The automobile industry is now working to their extreme level that they could create a new inventions around. In that invention electric vehicles are in the number one position. The previous design of electric vehicle tells that it is a silent vehicle. But now people are working in order to get a sound track for those cars.
http://www.bimmersclinicinc.com/

Ann Eueti's picture
Ann Eueti - Jan 19, 2013

I have a Prius and it is worrying that people can't hear you. I've even seen truckdrivers jump out of their skin when I purr by.