5

Facing water shortages, Indian farmers dig in


  • Photo 1 of 11

    Rajendra Singh, 52, at the headquarters of the organization he directs, Tarun Bharat Sangh (Indian Youth Association). Since the 1980s, the group has focused on community-based water management.

    - Jon Miller

  • Photo 2 of 11

    Rajendra Singh at the first water harvesting structure he built in the Alwar District of Rajasthan state.

    - Jon Miller

  • Photo 3 of 11

    A cloth map shows the locations of water harvesting structures in Alwar. Singh says there are now more than 10,000 structures in the area, all built by hand by community members.

    - Jon Miller

  • Photo 4 of 11

    The most common type of water harvesting structure in Alwar is a “check dam,” known locally as a johad. Different types of structures are used in other places.

    - Jon Miller

  • Photo 5 of 11

    Villagers move rocks for a new johad. Water harvesting goes back hundreds of years, but was largely abandoned with the arrival of tube wells and electric pumps.

    - Jon Miller

  • Photo 6 of 11

    Harshaye, 65, says he is confident that this area will be green and productive by next year.

    - Jon Miller

  • Photo 7 of 11

    Singh now spends most of his time on national and regional water policy issues. He says the Indian government is beginning to see the value of grassroots water management.

    - Jon Miller

  • Photo 8 of 11

    An employee of Singh’s nonprofit leads a field trip for university students from the central Indian city of Bhopal. Rainwater harvesting is enjoying a resurgence, but groundwater withdrawals still far outpace deposits.

    - Jon Miller

  • Photo 9 of 11

    In Lapuria village in central Rajasthan, local leader Laxman Singh (right) listens as villager Chhotu describes his work planting trees. Singh says water conservation has revitalized the village.

    - Jon Miller

  • Photo 10 of 11

    A girl draws drinking water from a well in Lapuria. The water table had dropped to more than 200 feet below the surface. Now it is 20 to 30 feet down, thanks to a range of conservation measures.

    - Jon Miller

  • Photo 11 of 11

    A farmer in Lapuria stands in a field of mustard. Community leader Laxman Singh says not only are people and livestock well fed, but so are birds and wild animals.

    - Jon Miller

Kai Ryssdal: There are, plus or minus, 7 billion people now living on this planet. By the middle of the century, the United Nations tells us it's gonna to be 9 billion. Among the many, many questions that raises is how we're gonna feed them all. The answer is complicated -- a mix of politics, culture, science, and traditions all affecting the global food supply.

Here's part of the science. The average person drinks a couple of quarts of water every day, but it takes more than a thousand times that to produce a day's worth of food. That's a problem everywhere, but especially in India, where scientists say nearly a third of that country's underground aquifers are already in critical condition and worry that the country is headed for a full-blown water crisis.

Today on our series "Food for 9 Billion," Jon Miller went to India to meet a man who's trying to do something about it.


Jon Miller: Rajendra Singh lives in a patch of forest hours from anywhere in the dry hills of eastern Rajasthan. It's dark when I get there. We eat dinner on the ground by an open fire, then he leads me to his office, lights a candle, settles on a mattress and tells me how he came to be famous as the "water man."

Rajendra Singh: When I came here I don't know about the water management, I don't know the water engineering. My background is in the medical science.

This was the 1980s, and Singh had recently finished a degree in traditional Indian medicine. Inspired by Gandhi, he decided to move to the poorest, driest, most godforsaken place in his area and build a health clinic and a school.

Singh: After seven month, one old man told me, Rajendra, we not need medicine and education. We need water. Without water we can't survive.

But Singh knew nothing about water. So he asked the old man what he should do. And the old man told him he should do what folks here used to do -- build a little dam to catch the rainwater that comes during the short, but intense annual monsoon.

Singh: So I start digging!

And kept digging -- for four years.

Singh: Some day 6 hours, some day 8 hours, some day 12 hours.

The water shortage back then was a sneak preview of the crisis India is facing today. For decades, the government had encouraged individual farmers to dig wells to tap into the groundwater. More than 20 million did. Food production went way up and the water level went way down. In dry places like this, it wasn't long before farmers couldn't reach it. Villages emptied out. The social fabric started to fray.

Singh: When I came here, just old women and old man and some child living here. Because no water.

Not that it never rained. It just all came at once, and most of it ran off. Rajendra Singh finally finished digging his pond just in time for the monsoon.

Singh: And my structure full with water.

Not only did the pond fill up, but the wells nearby started to fill. The dam wasn't just storing the water on the surface; it was sending it back into the ground, recharging the aquifer. It was just one pond, about three-and-a-half acres, but it was greening 500 acres around it. People from neighboring villages came to see.

Singh: So the wonderful thing is, in the fifth year, more than 30 villages start the work. The next year, in 200 villages.

Today, he says, more than 1,200 villages have built more than 10,000 rainwater harvesting structures over an area larger than the state of Delaware. Seven rivers that were dry most of the year are now flowing year-round. Farmers are back, there's plenty of food, and Rajendra Singh is the best-known figure in what's become a national grassroots rainwater harvesting movement.

Sound of gate

Singh: Come.

The next morning, Singh shows me around the rustic campus he's built as a sort of water education center. Peacocks and monkeys live in a forest that didn't used to be here. Singh is in his early 50s, with a broad face and a mostly-white beard. When he's excited, which is a lot, you can see the whites all around the irises of his eyes.

Singh: Yes, it is the completely arid area, no grasses. No tree! No moisture! But now, beautiful tree come up! Beautiful grasses coming up! Very healthy soil. And we are also healthy!

I can see the changes when I head out with Singh to look at projects. The valleys are green with fields of mustard in yellow flower. Villages are full of kids -- both human and goat. Around noon we stop at a stone and concrete dam almost 150 yards long, built by villagers with little outside help.

Singh: This work made by the community effort! No grant from the government. No grant from the World Bank or UN. Nothing!

Singh says rainwater harvesting is only part of the reason this area is back from the brink. He's also fought to keep out water-guzzling industries, like breweries and mines. He's convinced villagers to plant trees on the hillsides, and to change the way they manage their crops -- in some cases burying pots with holes in them to deliver water to plants drip by drip.

Singh: Water harvesting is not the solution, but water conservation and community-driven, decentralized water management is the solution for my country.

All of which makes perfect sense to Sanjay Pahuja, a water expert with the World Bank. He says rainwater harvesting has been great, especially for raising awareness. But the more urgent work is on reducing demand.

Sanjay Pahuja: You have a bucket with a big hole in it. You shouldn't be going around, running around the landscape trying to find more water to keep that bucket full. You fix the leak in the bucket.

He says that can be done mainly with existing technology, like drip irrigation, or leveling fields, or just planting crops that need less water.

Pahuja: If we look at the gap between supply and demand in 2050, 80 percent of that gap can be closed purely by these improvements -- which are going to increase water efficiency on the farms, without doing anything else.

For Pahuja, the biggest challenge is scaling up. Which doesn't necessarily mean thinking big. He says conditions can be dramatically different from place to place, so the key is to let communities take charge. But that takes coordination. With more than 600,000 villages, you can't count on charismatic personalities like Rajendra Singh to pop up wherever you need them.

Singh now spends most of his time trying to influence India's water policies. He says there has been progress; official attitudes are starting to change. In the meantime, work continues back home. Late in the day we walk a couple of miles up a dry valley, to the mouth of a steep box canyon. About a dozen men and women are clawing at the earth with picks, carrying metal bowls full of rocks on their heads, dumping the rocks on a pile.

The ground looks hopelessly parched, but a man named Harshaye, age 65, says they'll be farming here next year. And they'll have drinking water, and birds, and they'll build a temple so they can worship by the waterside. Singh beams with approval.

Singh: So this is the change. When I start, that time no hope, my dear. But now, not only hope -- confidence.

Rajendra Singh has learned a lot since he arrived here 27 years ago -- about water, about geology, about engineering, about politics. He's also learned that when you're facing long odds, confidence can be a very powerful tool.

In Rajasthan, India, I'm Jon Miller for Marketplace.


Ryssdal: Our series "Food for 9 Billion" is a collaboration with Homelands Productions, PBS NewsHour and the Center for Investigative Reporting. You can find pictures and other stories by visiting our special collection -- "Food for 9 Billion."

About the author

Jonathan Miller has been executive director of Homelands Productions since 2005.
Log in to post5 Comments

The series is barking up the wrong tree. The question is not: how can we produce more food? It is: how can we produce fewer people?

Millions of dollars are wasted every year on large water projects around the world that break, are abandoned, or prove to be unsustainable. Much can be done to reduce the global water scarcity problem by using solutions at a local level. In fact, by returning to techniques and solutions that people around the world have used for centuries before the large, engineered projects became the vogue.

The rainwater harvesting systems of dams and ponds that Rajendra Singh set up in India is a wonderful example of a local solution to water scarcity. In my blog (http://bit.ly/KZe1Uk), I describe other other methods used to sustainably harvest water on a small-scale, local level such as dew ponds, fog catchers, qanats, and seawater greenhouses.

Great case study about a grassroots initiative that effects change locally. Never underestimate the power of someone who is willing to dig a hole for 12 hours.

It's amazing you don't "do the math", and so are unaware the flaw in promoting water collection for helping Indian farmers who have overused their natural resources.

Once you recognize the pattern you find it’s a deep contradiction our general approach. You'll find SO many examples on Marketplace and in the popular literature on interventions for "sustainability", you’ll realized that these mysteriously unstudied "faith based solutions" for overstressed environments are for an impossible purpose. They’re all to let overstressed environments accommodate ever increasing demands… a kind of true widespread societal madness.

When you invent a way to supply unmet demands for one "bottleneck resource", what you do is multiply the demands on ALL others, pushing them into crisis too. You are not doing the math on that. You are NOT doing the math!

The real environmental problem, causing all our environments to become overstressed, is OUR OWN increasing productivity having made us over-productive in using the resources available. Becoming *increasingly productive* simply does not solve *that* problem, but just makes it far worse. It is in the late stages of throwing us into a downward spiral of cascading emergency responses. They will emerge as multiplying kinds that inevitably fail, unless we sharply reverse strategy in a very particular way..

That's the quite unavoidable physical systems physics.
It’s inherent in the natural behavior of growth systems, pushed beyond their limits.

synapse9.com/signals

You said it. Human overpopulation is root cause. Birth control is the solution. Getting family planning to all these areas of shortages will do a lot more good that all this expensive high tech stuff, which usually has unanticipated. detrimental side effects

With Generous Support From...