17

Search for teachers goes overseas

Michael Todd of the Alabama Education Association, a teachers union.

- Gigi Douban

Evangeline Amen of the Philippines is a physics teacher at an inner-city public high school in Birmingham, Ala.

- Gigi Douban

Jeff McDaniels, director of human resources for Birmingham, Ala., schools, was one of four administrators to go on a teacher recruiting trip to the Philippines.

- Gigi Douban

April Williams, president of the Birmingham, Ala., school board, says recruiting qualified teachers in math and science to an urban system like Birmingham's has been a continuing problem.

- Gigi Douban

To view this content, Javascript must be enabled and Adobe Flash Player must be installed.

Get Adobe Flash player

Evangeline Amen of the Philippines is a physics teacher at an inner-city public high school in Birmingham, Ala.

Jeff McDaniels, director of human resources for Birmingham, Ala., schools, was one of four administrators to go on a teacher recruiting trip to the Philippines.

April Williams, president of the Birmingham, Ala., school board, says recruiting qualified teachers in math and science to an urban system like Birmingham's has been a continuing problem.

TEXT OF STORY

Tess Vigeland: This just in: Next month, President Obama will appear in a back-to-school special with American Idol Kelly Clarkson and basketball star LeBron James. The 30-minute documentary will air on Viacom stations like MTV and BET. It's part of an education initiative by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation called "Get Schooled."

Of course, to get schooled, you need to have a qualified instructor. And you'd figure in this job market there'd be plenty of teachers vying for every slot. But from Maryland to California, school districts are turning their focus overseas to fill certain teaching jobs. From Birmingham, Ala., Gigi Douban reports.


GIGI DOUBAN: Evangeline Amen's 18-hour journey from the Philippines ended here in a sparsely furnished two-bedroom apartment. She was exhausted, but she's managed to unpack most of her things.

Amen came to teach physics at a public high school in Birmingham. She paid a recruiting agency about $10,000 to get here. That fee covers her teacher credentials, the immigration visa, travel, and the first few months' rent.

But she says it's worth it. Teachers in the Philippines make about $6,000 a year. Here, she'll be on the same pay scale as any other teacher, making more than $30,000. The hardest part was leaving behind her husband and two college-aged kids.

EVANGELINE Amen: This is for our family, to help our family.

Amen got connected with the Birmingham system through the recruiting firm Avenida International. Birmingham school officials visited the Philippines this summer and interviewed 89 candidates. Amen was among the seven teachers that they hired.

But in Alabama, the overall unemployment rate is more than 10 percent. So the decision to hire from abroad drew an enormous amount of criticism.

Michael Todd is with the Alabama Education Association, a teachers union. He says Birmingham should have scoured its own back yard -- even looked to neighboring states -- to fill those vacancies.

MICHAEL Todd: If you had to take a chance on someone, why wouldn't you take a chance on those folks who are already available in the pool?

That pool isn't as large as some might think, says April Williams. She's president of the Birmingham school board.

APRIL Williams: Math, science and English as a second language. Those are all critical needs areas around the country, and for Birmingham it's been a constant problem.

Williams says they've tried everything. Job fairs, partnering with universities, paying substitutes four times the regular rate. They've even offered a $6,000 signing bonus for math and science teachers. Still, none of it was enough to fill every teaching job by the first day of school.

Williams: You look at the salary. You look at some of the challenges that instructors face in urban settings. So then we said, well what else can we do?

What they say they couldn't do was fill those jobs with local applicants. Jeff McDaniels, director of human resources for the school system says that yes, there are many teachers out of work, but...

JEFF McDaniels: We need the credentials and experience to match what our instructional needs are, and we can't waver on that.

And they need teachers who will, say, show up for work every day. McDaniels says that was a big draw with the Filipino teachers.

McDaniels: All of these teachers have had perfect attendance with their current or previous employer. For us that means a lot.

Here at Parker High School, which sits across from a public housing project, Amen is teaching the first physics class offered at the school in years. The hallways are dismal and cramped. She has 17 students. But in the Philippines, she'd have 60 in a classroom.

Amen: For one textbook there would be two students using it. That's how we do it.

Just like in Birmingham, many of her Filipino students came from poverty. But her pupils in the Philippines were very motivated to study hard. Motivation, she says, will be the challenge with her American students.

In Birmingham, I'm Gigi Douban for Marketplace.

Pages

PRADEEP SRIVASTAVA's picture
PRADEEP SRIVASTAVA - Jun 22, 2010

i myself PRADEEP SRIVASTAVA engineering graduate 19 years before.i am teaching physics subject since last 16 years in india near DELHI. but i am interested for the same job in US or CANADA,please help me. PRADEEP SRIVASTAVA,NEW DELHI 22JUN2010.

PRADEEP SRIVASTAVA's picture
PRADEEP SRIVASTAVA - Jun 22, 2010

i myself PRADEEP SRIVASTAVA engineering graduate 19 years before.i am teaching physics subject since last 16 years in india near DELHI. but i am interested for the same job in US or CANADA,please help me. PRADEEP SRIVASTAVA,NEW DELHI 22JUN2010.

L N's picture
L N - Oct 14, 2009

I am a PhD chemist who is currently teaching at a small liberal arts college and at a community college. My application was ignored by the Birmingham system for an entire year. While I am not certified I _am_ eligible for alternate route certification. So don't tell me they "looked locally." It was a free trip to the tropics for administrators plain and simple.

Stella Jasmin Margaret's picture
Stella Jasmin M... - Sep 27, 2009

I am a teacher by profession \authorized to work in the U.S (English Literature being my major).I also am qualified to instruct as I have a Bachelors in Education, which is useful for teaching from 6th to the 12th grades here as I was told. But the fact is I have not been able to get any job in any schools I tried so far because of the requirement of certification and thereby having to go to college again which in turn is expensive when you are unemployed.All this is ironical ,since I have around ten years of teaching experience abroad in Colleges. If the authorities cannot help people like me do our part to help in the Education field ,this trend will continue and it is totally frustrating for people who are well qualified and can make so much of a difference to the communities in which they live.

Judi Grace's picture
Judi Grace - Sep 27, 2009

I feel local people should teach first. Americans are smart, and can teach any subject in any language. I do not mind exchange teachers with a one on one exchange, especially for foreign languages. I love native speakers teaching their native tongue. America is a melting pot anyway, but i noticed the foreign teachers tend to stay among themselves and not speak English or interact with Americans, especialy brown-skin Americans. I interact with everyone, when I am visiting or living in a foreign country. Many are just here for the money, and do not care about our children. The accents are very difficult to understand, when they are teachng Math. Math is hard enough.

Mary Ivancic's picture
Mary Ivancic - Sep 4, 2009

Why are we continuing to give jobs to foreign Americans instead of hiring our young people who can do a better job than thes people from foreign countries?

charles heilig's picture
charles heilig - Sep 2, 2009

I have a BS Math & MS Computer Science and was certified to teach secondary Math through grad school. As someone already pointed out, getting hired is all about cliques and nepotism. So while people with no knowledge of Math (but good contacts) are hired to teach Math here, I can't even get an interview. On the other hand, China, Japan, Russia and every other country to which I have applied has interviewed me. I landed several offers and strangely the best offer was in China and I should leave once my Visa is approved. So while the USA is about corruption and being anti-Math & anti-science, much of the world is not. I feel like I can go back into programming once I get to China as well. All the computer work left here is boring desk-top support that any high school flunky could do. America is in a death spiral so I'm bailing on this ship as quickly as I can.

Tonette Johnson's picture
Tonette Johnson - Aug 26, 2009

My wife and I are young black professionals in Birmingham. She is an Ob-Gyn Physician and I am an attorney. We both attended schools in Birmingham. I also have many family embers who are practicing phsycians and aswell as experienced educators in my family. The main problem with the school system in Birmingham is corruption. Unless you are in the "clique" you are not considered for any teaching position. Case in point, the former HR director hired her daughter to teach even though she did not have the proper teaching credentials, while she was handing out pink slips at the end of the year. Her daughter still retained her job. The same HR person who only has a Masters degree is making over $160,000 in a made up job - no joke. This is why the system has run out of money. It's sad that millions of dollars are misspent and mismanaged in educational systems each year, and the media looks the other way. The current HR person is really no better - he received his job because he is connected to one of the top administrators - not because he is qualified.

Rae Vincu's picture
Rae Vincu - Aug 25, 2009

It is sad the teachers in the US are unable to meet the credentials they needed to teach classes in algebra and in physics. I would like to believe that there are programs that the government are offering to assist teachers in attaining these credentials I grew up in the Philippines, completed my entire education there. I am proud of the teachers back home. They are hardworking individuals, very dedicated and they want every student to thrive in their education. Sad to say a lot of students here in the US take for granted their free education coming from a Third world country, it was instilled in our minds the importance of education in our future. It is not enough that you finish high school each student back home finds means and ways to go through college despite the hardship their family is experiencing. Just something to think about....

Reed Richards's picture
Reed Richards - Aug 24, 2009

To all those decrying the "deplorable" policy of bringing in foreign teachers, your ignorance shows why America is in the state it is.
Teachers in Ca? How many of them are willing to go to a slum in Alabama? Very few I bet, which is why we need to recruit from those who are willing.
As for the idea that there will be some language barrier, has it never occurred to you that perhaps other nations speak English? As a former US territory and protectorate, the Philippines has English as one of its two official languages. Trust me, most Filipinos speak better English than your average hillbilly from Alabama or ghetto slang slinging hip-hop homie.
BTW, Gary, it's not out-sourcing if we're recruiting them to bring them here. Get a clue.

Pages