PA looks at loosening beer law

Beer cans


Stacey Vanek-Smith: If you want to buy beer in Pennsylvania, you either have to go to a bar or restaurant or go to a wholesaler, where you have to buy a whole case. But that might be changing. From the Marketplace desk of it's noon somewhere, Joel Rose reports.

Joel Rose: Prohibition ended in the rest of the country almost 80 years ago. But in Pennsylvania, you still can't buy liquor, wine or beer in convenience stores. Or even in grocery stores. So it's a little weird to walk into the prepared foods section at Wegman's supermarket in Collegeville, Penn. and find a bar, with wooden stools, flat-screen TVs, even chatty bartenders. Laura Dimitrio is having a drink after work:

Laura Dimitrio: If you look around, and you feel like you're in a bar. You don't feel like you're in a grocery store.

Technically, you're not. Wegman's also has a restaurant, which is why it's allowed to sell alcohol. Store manager Blane Forkell says Wegman's has been selling beer to go in Pennsylvania for more than a year.

Blane Forkell: Our customers have overwhelmingly told us that they enjoy the choice of being able to make a purchase and not have to buy a full case of product.

And Wegman's may be just the beginning.

John Rafferty: All I can say is, free my beer!

At a raucous news conference in February, state senator John Rafferty announced a bill that would allow grocery and convenience stores to sell six-packs.

Rafferty: Consumer friendly, consumer-friendly, consumer-friendly. That's what we're trying to do.

But Rafferty is running into bitter opposition from Pennsylvania's 1,300 licensed beer stores, which are only allowed to sell by the case.

Steve Benko: $32.80, please.

Steve Benko owns Doc's World of Beer in Philadelphia. He's worried about what reformed beer laws would mean for him and his six employees. And Benko warns that they could lead to more underage drinking.

Benko: If I get fined, it's my tail. I'm responsible for watching underage drinking. If it goes into grocery stores or convenience stores, I'm not sure that person behind the counter really cares about who's buying the beer.

Even if the beer bill does pass, Pennsylvania would still have some of the toughest liquor laws in the country. If you want to buy wine or hard stuff, state stores are your only option.

In Philadelphia, I'm Joel Rose for Marketplace.

Log in to post2 Comments

OK and you guys say we have effed up blue laws....This has only to do with one thing. $$$$$$ What I dont understand is that these beer shops will make more money when they can sell 2x as much prodcut because people wont need to buy a whole case. As for underage drinking that is bogus PA has just as high of an under age drinking rate as any other state. Move on PA join the rest of the US. "6 pack run" Now if we can just have a 6pack run in GA on a Sunday. Oh well baby steps.

Sale of alcoholic beverages in PA is just another example of [1] after-math of "prohibition," and its repeal, and [2] - more pertinent now - the "protected" retailers not wanting to give up their commercial "niche" or "retail-market-corner." This protected - by law - retail sales exists in many states - likely not all - didn't count them - in various combinations.

Most important - state legislators protecting the retailers "monopolistic" niche. Like, here in Ohio, we have many sources for my vodka and beer - but at state controlled prices. Like, I had fun driving to Indiana, with my best man, to buy my wedding reception booze at cheap "un-controlled" prices.

With Generous Support From...