6

Hospital staffers: Health care needs fix

Tom Rosenthal, a kidney transplant surgeon at UCLA, who is listening closely to what the candidates say about healthcare

- Sarah Gardner

Patti Taylor, RN at UCLA

- Sarah Gardner

David Feinberg, CEO, UCLA Hospital

- Patti Taylor, RN at UCLA

David White, EMT, UCLA

- Sarah Gardner

Nevine Hanna, med student, UCLA

- Sarah Gardner

To view this content, Javascript must be enabled and Adobe Flash Player must be installed.

Get Adobe Flash player

TEXT OF STORY

Kai Ryssdal: For today's installment of our election series, Interested Parties, Sarah Gardner looked into what people in the health care trenches want from Washington.


Tape of hospital page: Kelly Clarr to the central work area, please. Kelly to the central work area, please.

Sarah Gardner: It's mid-morning in the ER at UCLA Medical Center in Los Angeles. This is one of the best hospitals in the country, according to U.S. News and World Report. It's also one of the busiest. The staff here treats over 70,000 patients each year. Everybody from surgeons to technicians is ready to spring into action. A few, literally.

David White: Everybody's always experimenting with footwear, because we are, you know, on the go.

Emergency medical technician David White wears shoes with springy coils on the soles. He's on his feet 12 hours a day and the shoes help. White does everything from meeting patients on the helipad to doing CPR. He says the ER here can be as clogged as an LA freeway, in part, because many of their walk-ins aren't emergencies. They're ordinary folks using the ER for ordinary health care problems, like flu or stomach troubles.

White: Y'know we're fortunate, you know, on a bad day our wait here might be six or seven hours. You go to some of the other county hospitals, if you're there less than 12 hours you don't even bother going up to ask: Am I next?

Here's the surprise. White says the people seeking basic care here in the ER aren't just uninsured immigrants or Hollywood freelancers. They're also professionals with plenty of coverage who've run into another traffic jam trying to get an appointment to see their doctors. They either wait or give up and end up in a health crisis. White believes the U.S. needs universal health coverage, with an emphasis on preventive care.

White: And I don't know that totally socialized medicine is necessarily the answer; I do think that it's kind of a basic right that everyone should have access to health care and have access to good health care.

White's view is a common one here. He envisions a system where everybody's covered somehow, whether totally through the government or a combination of public and private insurance. And Washington would have to figure out the details. fast. But everybody's skeptical. Nurse Patty Taylor says the first thing Congress should do is, quote, "get the pharmacy lobby out of Washington D.C." But does she believes Congress will do it?

Patty Taylor: No, I think a lot of Washington is bought out by lobbyists. I truly believe that.

Taylor started as a nurse 44 years ago, treating wounded soldiers in Viet Nam. Her army career took her all over the world, and she says she admires Western Europe's health care system the most.

Taylor: They may have a waiting list to get a certain type of procedure, you know, whatever, but they're doing very well.

Tom Rosenthal: There's absolutely no doubt in my mind that we're not ready for that.

That's Tom Rosenthal, a kidney transplant surgeon at UCLA.

Rosenthal: Hi, guys. How's everything goin'? It looks pretty busy here.

As Rosenthal walks through the surgical recovery area, he says, yes, a European health care system is probably more equitable but it's not perfect. He wants both the presidential candidates to start grappling with the economics of health care reform. Take Obama, he says.

Rosenthal: He said in front of some rally that we need to cover everybody and we need to do so at lower cost. I don't know how you do that. It's kind of like it's not a serious dialogue.

Covering everybody, say the experts, won't come cheap. Between all our pharmaceuticals, new technologies and longer living, health care's just getting more expensive. And taxpayers can only afford so much. But the hospital's CEO David Feinberg says when he talks about the need for rationing care, people look at him like he's crazy.

David Feinberg: Everyone wants low health care cost. But when your grandma is sick, you want her in the best intensive care unit, you want a 150 specialists to see her, and if they say, well, we could do this last procedure and it may help her; many people say, oh, let's go for it.

Feinberg says if he could talk to the president, he'd tell him we need to start thinking about rationed care, even if it's controversial. He'd also tell him the incentives in health care are all backwards. Doctors and hospitals don't make big bucks practicing preventive care or promoting healthy lifestyles. Meanwhile, he says, Americans should look themselves in the mirror.

Feinberg: You know, we make up 5 percent of the world's population and consume 50 percent of the illegal drugs. This is a country that takes things to excess.

Half our health care costs would disappear, Feinberg insists, if we stopped smoking, ate less, exercised more and consumed less drugs and alcohol. In Los Angeles, I'm Sarah Gardner for Marketplace.

About the author

Sarah Gardner is a reporter on the Marketplace sustainability desk covering sustainability news spots and features.
Archie Phillips's picture
Archie Phillips - Oct 28, 2008

We lived in Europe for ten years and came to respect the National Health Systems. When our daughter became ill, the first experience we had was a house call because she was too ill to go to the doctor's office, which was just down the street. When she was hospitalized, my wife stayed there with her. We had the top European blood disease specialist in attendance. There was no cost for all that, other than the income tax. On another occas
ion, when I booked an appointment for my annual check up, my physician asked what was wrong. When I explained my request for a check up, he said the reason I had those, in the States, was so my doctor could drive his Mercedes. He agreed to give me a check up but asked me to come back when I had a medical problem.

Gracia Berrocal's picture
Gracia Berrocal - Oct 1, 2008

health care costs could be cut in half tomorrow if we switched from disease maintenance ala big pharma to real healthcare. Consumers are getting the info they need from the internet/support groups--better quality and cheaper!!

Brad Boyle's picture
Brad Boyle - Sep 29, 2008

I've got news for Tom Rosenthal.

Obama's goal to "cover everybody, at lower cost" is not a dream. It's socialized health care.

By eliminating the administrative waste of hundreds of insurance companies and thousands of insurance forms, Canada covers everybody, all the time, at a lower per capita cost than the United States.

For the every person who waits for "rationed procedures" in Canada (and eventually get them), dozens in the US who get no treatment at all.

There's only one catch. This pill you'll have to swallow whole.

Down the hatch.

Deborah Pierce's picture
Deborah Pierce - Sep 29, 2008

Health care in this country is already rationed, but not by government. It's currently rationed by the incredibly high costs brought on by the for-profit health insurance industry. Dr. Newsom (above)has it right, and Dr. Rosenthal and Administrator Feinberg have it wrong. We need to institute government-provided health insurance, which is quite different from government-provided health care.

Christine Newsom M.D.'s picture
Christine Newso... - Sep 29, 2008

I am a physician, and I couldn't believe the disinformation I heard when the surgeon in your piece on Health care said that he didn't know of any way of insuring everyone for less than is currently spent. The US spends over $6000 per capita on health care and still leaves nearly 50 million uncovered. Countries with a single-payer system, which is every developed country except ours, pay around $3000 per capita and cover EVERYONE. How? By leaving out the 35% of your premium that goes to administration, marketing, and profits of the insurance companies.
Compare that to the 3% overhead of Medicare. Can anyone doubt the power of the insurance lobby?

Thomas Hubbell's picture
Thomas Hubbell - Sep 29, 2008

Being "business news for the rest of us" you should know that a Single Payer National Health Plan will cost NO MORE than what we are ALREADY spending on health care, and it will cover everyone pretty well. Why? Because we waste so much money on late care of chronic illness and we spend it in the wrong place, the ER instead of primary doctors' offices. Check out PNHP.org. >60% of doctors want single payer.
Thanks. TH