How to make good decisions? Hint: A pros/cons list won't help

A pros and cons list.

Image of Decisive: How to Make Better Choices in Life and Work
Author: Chip Heath, Dan Heath
Publisher: Crown Business (2013)
Binding: Hardcover, 336 pages

Conventional wisdom says before you make a decision you should make a list of pros and cons, but Chip and Dan Heath say that's wrong.  The brothers are co-authors of "Decisive: How To Make Better Choices in Life and Work."

"The pros and cons list is a good way of setting up a situation where you've got potentially one option that you're doing thumbs up and thumbs down on," says Chip. "Good decision-making starts with having multiple options available to you. Good decision-making involves collecting information that may contradict your initial opinions that you can sit at home with your pros and cons list and come up with a beautiful justification for whatever you wanted to do in the first place. What we're trying to do is widen out the process of making a good decision."

Dan Heath says one of the classic villains of decision making is what psychologists call "narrow framing" -- a temptation to get stuck in making decisions in a "whether or not" frame. Whether or not you should buy an iPad. Whether or not you should quit your job.

"What the research tells us is if we can just generation another option -- just one or two -- it greatly increases the chance we're going to make a good decision," says Dan.

Dan says one of the most important principals of decision-making is to trust the actual experiences of other people over our own instincts.

"We're always wise to trust the experience of other people over our own intuitions. For instance, if you're thinking of where you're going to go out to dinner tonight, you might be wise enough to go onto Yelp and look at the reviews and trust the place that has 100 good reviews over your own judgment about which menu looks good," says Dan. "When it comes to people's portfolios, they totally throw that logic out of the window."

The Heaths say part of being a good decision maker is knowing when not to trust yourself -- and figuring out how to not let your emotions get the best of you.

"Often the best thing we can do -- especially when it comes to something like retirement -- is get out of [your] emotional melee and create some distance," says Dan.

About the author

In more than 20 years in public radio, Barbara Bogaev has served as the longtime guest host of NPR’s flagship program Fresh Air with Terry Gross, as well as host of APM’s news and culture magazine, Weekend America and the weekly national documentary series, Soundprint.
Image of Decisive: How to Make Better Choices in Life and Work
Author: Chip Heath, Dan Heath
Publisher: Crown Business (2013)
Binding: Hardcover, 336 pages

Comments

I agree to American Public Media's Terms and Conditions.
With Generous Support From...