5

The costs and the limits of school security

Children return to school on Dec. 18, 2012 in Newtown, Conn.

To view this content, Javascript must be enabled and Adobe Flash Player must be installed.

Get Adobe Flash player

A lot of parents are worried about their schools' safety after the Newtown tragedy and the headlines reflect that. Time magazine's reads: School Security: Why it's so hard to keep kids safe. Fox News has: Massacre sparks school security alerts nationwide. Well, here's the Marketplace-y headline: Does spending more on security really make schools safer?

Craig Hockenberry, the principal of Oyler a public school that goes from pre-K through high school is proud of his security upgrades, part of a $21 million school renovation. (Marketplace has been following Oyler's progress in a year-long education series.)

Principal Hockenberry wants the school to be the beacon of safety in Lower Price Hill, a poor Cincinnati neighborhood where crime and blight are everywhere. And, he's willing to pay for it. "The police, I can give you that figure, is upwards of about 30 some thousand dollars a year that I set aside from our general fund budget: the cameras, a quarter of a million dollars in cameras, probably. I don't know what the doors cost, but at the end of the day anything that could slow down a potential shooter or a potential problem to give the good guys time to respond is something very important to us," says Hockenberry.

Dan Domenech is the executive director of the American Association of School Administrators. He says Craig Hockenberry is like most school administrators -- deeply concerned with kids' safety, even when budget shortfalls demand a long list of cuts.

"Their have been a huge number of teacher lay-offs because of that, professional development... they've cut back on instructional materials and supplies, but nowhere on the list has school security appeared," he says.

Annette Fuentes, author of "Lockdown High: When The Schoolhouse Becomes a Jailhouse," says security surveillance and hardware can range from a couple of thousand to tens of thousands of dollars. And, she says spending all that money on high-priced equipment wouldn't have stopped the Newtown shooter.

"Adam Lanza was determined to get into the school and he had a small arsenal of high powered weaponry to get in," says Fuentes. "Especially at time of budget deficits for public schools investing in high tech security and more armed police is not the way to go."

Curt Lavarello,  the executive director of the School Safety Advocacy Council and a former school police officer, says expensive security systems CAN make schools safer as does, "common sense, you want to create an environment that's open to dialogue where kids feel comfortable talking to adults." Lavarello says training teachers and students to speak up when someone looks suspicious, or when bullying takes place -- that's cheap -- and, it works.

About the author

Shereen Marisol Meraji is a reporter for Marketplace’s Wealth & Poverty Desk.
legabox's picture
legabox - Feb 14, 2013

Children are our future, school security is very necessary.

http://www.legabox.com

Redbarn's picture
Redbarn - Dec 20, 2012

Perhaps Mr. Lavarello missed the news for the last several days but we're not talking about bullying or some weirdo lurking outside the playground. Keeping Adam Lanza and other heavily armed mass murders out of schools does require quite a bit more than an atmosphere where children can talk to adults. It seems like Newtown, CT was a town where people could talk to each other, children and adults.

resourcer@aol.com's picture
resourcer@aol.com - Jan 6, 2013

No, I actually didn't miss the news for the past few days and did over 30 interviews about a number of issues surrounding school safety. I have been in the school safety arena now for over 25 years as both a school based law enforcement officer/supervisor. What I have been saying is that it is more then just a "Gun" issue, or more then just a "mental health" issue, its about schools and communities collaborating and addressing school safety as partners. When the US Secret Service did their school shooter threat assessment, the one common issue among school shootings was the element of bullying victimization, as well as the fact that in many of the incidents, other students knew of the potential violent threat, yet didnt report it. So making sure you have a climate where kids feel comfortable is one of many factors. School Based Officers do more then just "stand guard" at a schools entry. They become mentors to kids and create an environment whereby kids feel comfortable approaching officers. They also teach classes and assist the school in training staff on critical incident response. http://www.schoolsafety911.org

jadiggins@gmail.com's picture
jadiggins@gmail.com - Dec 19, 2012

Thank you for your story on the cost of school security. I couldn't disagree with Ms. Fuentes more. If the same number of children and teachers at Sandy Hook were killed in a fire instead of by a shooter, the district and nation would be engaged in an all-out effort to reform building codes, put in sprinklers, and more. No child has died in a school in over 50 years and the many redundant systems have worked to make our children safe. We absolutely need at least one armed policeman at each school - these gunman are killing more and younger children. Media coverage amplifies this effect. Someone out there is not watching this coverage in horror like most of us. That person is inspired. We can no longer live in denial - we have to change the way we think about school safety and security.

A. Diggins

mastrbruce's picture
mastrbruce - Dec 20, 2012

I disagree. An armed police officer at each school? Then what? One at each movie theatre, McDonald's, and every other public venue? Welcome to the police state.