2

Is the equal employment opportunity census misleading?

A sample Census form is seen during the kick off of the 2010 Census Portrait of America Road Tour in Times Square January 4, 2010 in New York City.

To view this content, Javascript must be enabled and Adobe Flash Player must be installed.

Get Adobe Flash player

In its nearly 50 years of existence, the EEO-1 has never contained a category for national origin, and it's time to change it.

With the current census form, a black employee born in Paris who works full time in the United States is identified the same as an African American. There is no way to differentiate between an Asian born in Singapore and an Asian American born in Sacramento. By conflating foreign-born with native-born workers, it is impossible to tell whether the increase in diversity among corporate leaders in this country is the result of grassroot cultivation or an influx of well-educated immigrants.

In a study of executive officers at Fortune 100 companies, I found that immigrants are doing very well at the top of the ladder. In fact, they are over-represented. In 2009, more than half of the Latino executive officers were born outside of the U.S. They came from eight different countries in Latin America. More than half of the Asian executive officers were also born beyond our borders (most came from India). Many of these executives are from wealthy families in countries where they were part of the majority. They are not traditional American minorities who may have struggled historically from discrimination. 

Immigration is a cherished part of the American experience, and it invigorates our economy. Identifying immigrants in the EEO-1 would not be used to stigmatize them. Instead, it would help clarify whether our efforts to improve the education, training and integration of homegrown minorities are paying off. We need to understand why foreign-born minorities are promoted more and whether the United States is providing greater opportunity for immigrants than it does for its own.

Susan E. Reed is an investigative journalist and author of the book, The Diversity Index: The Alarming Truth about Diversity in Corporate America…and What Can Be Done About It.

About the author

Susan E. Reed is an investigative journalist and author of the book "The Diversity Index: The Alarming Truth about Diversity in Corporate America…and What Can Be Done About It."
RichardNYC's picture
RichardNYC - Sep 26, 2012

If most Asian executives born abroad started with an advantage because they are from higher castes or socio-economic groups, how would revealing national origin on the EEO-1 "help clarify whether our efforts to improve the education, training and integration of homegrown minorities are paying off?" I'd much rather see a study of why being named Pradeep or Sanjay ironically seems to carry more weight in financial journalism or management consulting than Paul or Sam.

Call Me Missouri's picture
Call Me Missouri - Oct 24, 2012

This is actually pretty easy to explain...

If companies had to report both Ethnicity and National Origin, it would allow us to not count anyone with a National Origin of any country other than the USA as a Minority.

Chinese immigrants to the US are not and should not be considered Minorities in the US because they can always go home and be in the Majority in China and when they were growing up in China they were not disadvantaged because they were always in the Majority. Understand? It's not hard.

The purpose of the programs that require this reporting is to force corporations to do what they should have been doing all along... Hire poor, less fortunate people... provide them with some training... give them a job... give them a break for Pete's sake.

It was not the purpose of these programs to have corporations import diversity from foreign countries.

We cannot allow the policies/procedures currently in place to continue if we are serious about reducing poverty in the US. The new field would help quite a bit.

Personally I think there should be 4 more fields added... Born Citizen, Naturalized Citizen, H1-B Visa, and TIN (Undocumented Immigrant). If you are not a Born Citizen then you should not be counted as a Minority, regardless of Ethnicity, in the government mandated EEO-1 Report or Affirmative Action Plans that all Federal Contractors are required to keep and maintain. It's that simple.

Now that I have found this article (it wasn't linked to on the MarketPlace page the day I heard this for some reason), I will be sending it to everyone I know. Very Insightful.