4

San Bernardino struggles after bankruptcy

San Bernardino Civic Plaza. Struggling after the 2008 economic crash, the city filed for bankruptcy on August 1, 2012.

- Russell Calkins

A closed department store is just another sign of economic stress in the city. Norton Air Force Base and Kaiser Steel, the city's two previous big employers, have also closed.

- Russell Calkins

San Bernadino is the county seat of San Bernardino County, the largest in the lower 48. It's also one of the nation's poorest: per capita income is $15,600.

- Russell Calkins

The San Bernardino International Airport cost over $220 million and has not seen any passenger traffic as of yet.

- Russell Calkins

Hans Van der tow spoke at the SBC Town Hall meeting. HIs message: The city needs less criminals and more tax paying citizens.

- Russell Calkins

The $220 Million San Bernardino International Airport has yet to see a single passenger.

- Russel Calkins

Al Palazzo grew up in San Bernardino. He has a 100 year plan for the city

- Russel Calkins

Tim Prince founded the Citizens for Accountable City Government

- Russell Calkins

Concepcion Powell, founder and president of the US Women's Hispanic Grocers Association. Her American flag used to sit behind her until someone stole it.

- Russell Calkins
- Russel Calkins

An outdoor mall with no shops.

- Russel Calkins

Draymond Crawford is head of graffiti clean up in San Bernardino. He has been trying to convince City Hall to install parking meters to generate new revenue

- Russel Calkins

To view this content, Javascript must be enabled and Adobe Flash Player must be installed.

Get Adobe Flash player

The San Bernardino International Airport cost over $220 million and has not seen any passenger traffic as of yet.

Al Palazzo grew up in San Bernardino. He has a 100 year plan for the city

In 1948 brothers Richard and Maurice McDonald decided to reinvent their family barbeque joint. They came up with a new technique for making French fries that used desert winds to dry potatoes in a shed behind the restaurant. But the most popular item on their new menu was the 15-cent hamburgers. The place which they called McDonald's was located on E Street, the main drag of San Bernardino, California. They couldn't have picked a better time and place.

Residents who grew up in San Bernardino told me that the movie "American Graffiti" is a perfect example of what life on E Street was like in the '50s and '60s. Hot rods would cruise the street at a crawl and drivers would talk to each other through their open car windows. People would line up on the sidewalk with lawn chairs. Every summer night was a parade.

Most people in San Bernardino at that time worked at Norton Air Force Base or Kaiser Steel, companies that provided thousands of good middle-class jobs. People were coming to the city in droves on the newly paved Route 66. The city was immortalized in the song “Route 66” which The Rolling Stones covered on June 5, 1964 when they played their first show in America at the Orange Show Fairgrounds San Bernardino.

But the boom didn't last. Both Norton Air Force Base and Kaiser Steel closed, and the city never recovered. Today, more than half of San Bernardino's population receives public assistance. The per capita income is $15,600. Detroit is the only city in the country that is poorer. The city was on its knees and the recession dealt the final blow. On August 1 of this year San Bernardino filed for bankruptcy.

E Street Today
Al Palazzo Grew up in San Bernardino. He remembers working as a bus boy at a coffee shop on E street. He took me on a tour of the city last week and showed me how dramatically the city has changed since he was a kid. I sat in the passenger seat of his Toyota Corolla as he pointed out the dozens of vacant lots that line the once booming E Street.

"This was the main drag in San Bernardino? This is a slum," he said. "This is not a viable commercial street. What's going to bring it back? Change the housing."

Palazzo believes that the key to fixing San Bernardino is to build new middle class, high density housing along E street and other areas close to downtown. But changing the housing is just one idea. Nearly everyone in San Bernardino has a solution for how to get the city back on its feet. One plan is to use eminent domain to seize foreclosed homes. Another involves a parent takeover the public schools. One person told me the city's 200-year-old sewage system should be at the top of the list. 

Citizen Groups Form
Tim Prince is an attorney in San Bernardino. His father served as the city attorney for 28 years. Prince is the founder of the Citizens for Accountable City government, one of several groups that have popped up in San Bernardino. He thinks the budget deficit was caused by the police and fire unions.

"There's no doubt about it -- 73 percent of the city budget goes to police and fire union benefits," Prince explained.

Tim Prince founded the Citizens for Accountable City Government. Photo by Russell Calkins

Another group, The SBC Town hall has a different view.  I attended the group's most recent meeting at the San Bernardino Elks Lodge, which sits on a hill overlooking the San Bernardino valley. When I arrived an hour early the only other person in the parking lot was  a tall man with shaggy gray hair fumbling with a couple of giant posters and an easel in the triple-digit heat. Sixty-three-year-old local business owned Hans Van Der Touw was one of the speakers at the event.

The mostly white-haired crowd went wild for Van Der Touw. One person demanded he run for mayor. Van Der Touw believes everything but public safety should be cut. In his speech, he compared San Bernardino to Rome, a city under siege by barbarians.

"The city hall is not in charge of the city," he said at the meeting. "It's the criminals. They are the ones that have been able to chase the working middle class out of the city."

A few days after attending the San Bernardino City Town Hall meeting, I sat in on a meeting held by the Concerned Citizens Coalition -- which was started by Concepcion Powell, the president and founder of the U.S. Hispanic Women's Grocers Association.

She's been in the grocery business a long time. At seven years old she opened her first store, selling candy and cookies out of the back of her family's home. By the age of 12 she had savings in the bank. Powell is 53 now. She believes that the key to San Bernardino's prosperity is the city's international airport.

"They invested $228 million in the international airport is sitting there it looks like it's abandoned," she said.

Grounded: The San Bernardino Airport never took off. Photo by Russell Calkins

Powell wants to transform the empty airport into a global business hub and invite foreign investment into the city. Though these community groups don't always agree on how to save San Bernardino, they do agree on one thing -- the current government is dysfunctional. Powell says the city council, mayor and attorney act like children.

"Yes, they're just big kids," he said. "Like first grade, second grade getting into these kid fights and just get carried away."

Of course San Bernardino's problems are much more adult. The crime rate is one of the highest in the nation. The education system is a mess. The city's infrastructure is in disarray and more than a third of the city's residents fall below the poverty line.

The biggest question might be, "Where to begin?"

Marketplace will try to answer that question with our series of reports on San Bernardino.


CORRECTION: The text version of this story has been edited for grammar and punctuation.

About the author

David Weinberg is a reporter on Marketplace's Sustainability Desk.
thenick's picture
thenick - Oct 21, 2012

I grew up in San Bernardino, more specifically I grew up in the Verdemont (that wasn't even the name when we moved in), Cajon pass area.

This is the low down. Listen up because I'm only going to come back here an write this once.

This guy Hans Van Der Touw, is EXACTLY the reason why San Bernardino can't get back on it's feet. The crime ISN'T that bad. It really really isn't. I know downtown is worse than the outlying areas, but the POLICE make it even worse. They keep hiring more and more police and then guess what??? They find more crime. They are exacerbating it. The place is a POLICE STATE. Ok.

That Mexican woman, whatever her name is, is ABSOLUTELY CORRECT. They need to kick out that old white racist moron out of the city, because that is the GARBAGE that is holding back the city. The world is not Route 66 and old cars anymore. It's electric cars, computers, and jobs.

Open the bleeping airport. Make it cheap. Better yet get a passenger train there from L.A. all the way to Las Vegas. That would save both San Bernardino and Las Vegas in one shot.

The place unnaturally sprung out of the desert because of external funds. It doesn't have the resources by itself to support it's level of population. It NEEDS the outside so if it wants to survive it needs transportation. It needs a vain. It needs life from elsewhere and about the only thing it has going for it is a desperate population and a lot of land. They need that airport to open.

Lets get one things straight for sure though, the POLICE in that city are CHOKING it. They run it like a gang. It continues to report high crime rates because that keeps the police force supplied. It's all fake. Throw them all out. The police in San Bernardino are a cancer and they run the city like a mob. The national guard should come in and disband it. The citizens are like any other small town, but long ago some police got this idea that if they could jack up the crime rates they could become the authority and they did. That is the real problem with San Bernardino.

OPEN THAT AIRPORT, Get a train, and by all mean kick out those police who treat the city like a prison. Want proof. Go to downtown San Bernardino and look at how many cars on the streets are police. It's over half. Two thirds of the cars on the streets of downtown San Bernardino are police. The place is choked. Get them out of there.

I hope they build a train there and I hope they get that airport up because that could really give industry a reason to come. I might even come back and land my plane there for lunch.

Now everyone knows. Who will do something.

Peter C's picture
Peter C - Sep 30, 2012

We just moved our small manufacturing company to San Bernardino. We have found it to be an excellent place to do business with quite a few advantages over our previous location in Corona.

- We were able to purchase a building for a very good price
- San Bernardino is in a California Enterprise Zone which gives us beneficial tax credits for hiring.
- Both the City and County of San Bernardino have been incredibly helpful in getting us set up there and feeding us good quality job candidates. In particular, the City has helped clear up some bureaucratic snafus that might otherwise have taken a while.
- We find the area to have a very rich pool of skilled labor.
- The climate is perfect for solar and we are in the process of building enough solar to produce about 80% of our considerable electricity needs.

The biggest downside of course is the crime rate. Our air conditioners were stolen from our roof the night before we started moving in. Our security costs are considerably higher than our previous location.

I would agree with the folks that say the area has great potential; that is why we have staked the future of our business there. Fixing housing is definitely important, but I think attracting businesses will go a long way towards reducing crime and building a solid base for the City.

vickiesque's picture
vickiesque - Sep 28, 2012

I worked in downtown San Bernardino 15 years ago. Even then it was declining, losing businesses, with no place to eat lunch or shop. Now it is like a war zone, scary and dilapidated. In contrast, its neighbor, downtown Riverside, is a hub of workers, attractive historic buildings, restaurants, the restored Fox, and many other appealing diversions. For many years, San Bernardino has struggled and it still seems to be directionless. How can it be saved by an "international" airport when nearby Ontario has suffered losses in its air traffic, returning its numbers to the 1980s?

MichaelMarketplace's picture
MichaelMarketplace - Sep 27, 2012

I'm sorry to sound hypercritical, but did you guys just lay off an editor, or what? The punctuation, spelling, and usage in the text version of this story is riddled with foulups:

"The city was immortalixed" --> immortalized

"how dramatically the city has changes" --> changed

"his Toyota Coroll" -->Corolla

" back on it's feet" --> its (Google its it's)

"parent take over the the public schools" --> takeover (see link below) *of* the public schools.
http://www.grammarglitchcentral.com/2012/04/is-it-takeover-or-take-over-...

"I attended the groups most recent "--> group's

Come on, folks ...