1

Federal borrowing virtually free now

Some economists advocate borrowing the money to pay for extending tax cuts and unemployment benefits.

To view this content, Javascript must be enabled and Adobe Flash Player must be installed.

Get Adobe Flash player

Jeremy Hobson: Well if all goes according to plan today, the payroll tax cut that we've all been getting this year will be extended by another two months. On the upside, that tax cut has meant more money in our pockets. On the downside, it has put less money into the Social Security trust fund because that's what this particular tax pays for. Now, with the nation's debt currently exceeding $15 trillion, you might think it's no time for Washington to go further into the red.

But as our Washington bureau chief John Dimsdale reports, some economists say that's exactly what we should be doing.


John Dimsdale: Right now the federal government can borrow for less interest than the rate of inflation.

Andrew Fieldhouse: Meaning investors are paying the government to hold onto cash because they don't see any good investment opportunities.

Andrew Fieldhouse is with the Economic Policy Institute. He says the government should take advantage of that by borrowing at zero interest and extending payroll tax cuts and unemployment benefits. That money, he says, will help get the economy going.

Fieldhouse: When customers go out and spend money and another million Americans are working because of the payroll tax cut, you're collecting more tax revenue.

Revenue that helps the government pay back its cheap loans. But conservative economists like Johns Hopkins professor Steve Hanke say consumers care more about growing government debt than more stimulus.

Steve Hanke: It makes people anxious and worried about the future. They tend to hunker down and don't spend the money.

Hanke says even if borrowing is free, the money still adds to the deficit, and won't do any good for the economy.

In Washington, I'm John Dimsdale for Marketplace.

About the author

As head of Marketplace’s Washington, D.C. bureau, John Dimsdale provides insightful commentary on the intersection of government and money for the entire Marketplace portfolio.
dmulliga's picture
dmulliga - Dec 24, 2011

You are correct that this is a very good time for the government to be borrowing; and unemployment benefits are certainly a good thing for the economy. However it is Never a good time to violate public trust by raiding trust funds. These two are entirely different issues that should not be tied to one another. You are making these issues more confusing and misleading your listeners by lumpping them together. And further, think about this: simply extending a tax cut does not provide anyone with more money to spend, or encourage new hiring; people already expect this money; it is already spent; and already factored into hiring decisions; therefor it has no economic impact. Nothing could be simpler.