7

Can good unemployment numbers be bad?

Commentator Robert Reich says the defining political issue of 2012 won’t be the government’s size. It will be who government is for.

To view this content, Javascript must be enabled and Adobe Flash Player must be installed.

Get Adobe Flash player

Kai Ryssdal: There are still 10 months -- give or take -- until election day. A lot can happen between now and then. But the economy's still going to be a big issue. One of the key indicators of how things are going -- the unemployment rate -- has been falling.

But commentator Robert Reich points out that's not necessarily good news for the president.


Robert Reich: Two years ago the unemployment rate was 9.9 percent. Now it's 8.5 percent. That's good news for President Obama. Voters tend to pay more attention to the direction the economy is moving than to how bad or good it is in the months before election day. The trend looks promising.

This is until you count the number of working-age Americans who have stopped looking for work over the past two years because they can't find a job. Add to that all the young people too discouraged even to start looking.

You see, the Bureau of Labor Statistics counts people as unemployed only if they're looking for work. If they stop or are too discouraged even to enter the job market, they're not counted.

If all these discouraged workers were included in the count, today's unemployment rate wouldn't be 8.5 percent. It would be 9.5 percent. That's only a bit down from the 9.9 percent unemployment rate two years ago.

But the genuinely good news, is the job market is improving a bit. The Bureau of Labor Statistics tells us that 200,000 new jobs were added in December. That doesn't put much of a dent in the 10 million jobs we're down since the recession began -- jobs we've either lost or need to add to keep up with population growth. At this rate we won't return to our pre-recession level of employment until 2019. But, hey, it's at least the right direction.

Yet here's the irony. This little bit of good news is likely to raise the hopes of many people who have been too discouraged to look for jobs.  Many of them will now start looking.

But if they don't find a job -- and, let's face it, the chances are still very slim -- they'll now be counted as unemployed.

This means the unemployment rate is likely to edge upward in coming months -- which will be bad for the President, because it will look as though the employment trend is going in the wrong direction again.

This is how a little bit of good economic news can mean bad news politically.


Ryssdal: Robert Reich teaches public policy at the University of California Berkeley.  His most recent book is called "Aftershock: The Next Economy and America's Future." Take a second to send us your thoughts.  

About the author

Robert Reich is chancellor's professor of public policy at the University of California, Berkeley. He has served in three national administrations, most recently as secretary of labor under President Bill Clinton.
linmei800's picture
linmei800 - Feb 23, 2012

The bags <strong><a href="http://hermesbirkin4cheap.com/Hermes-Kelly-Shoulder-Handbag-Orange-Golde... birkin orange</a></strong> are handmade <strong><a href="http://hermesbirkin4cheap.com/Hermes-Birkin-HandBags-35CM-cid-422.html">... birkin 35</a></strong> in France by expert artisans. The company's <strong><a href="http://hermesbirkinkellydiscount.com/Hermes-Birkin-Bag-35CM-Orange-Silve... birkin orange</a></strong> signature saddle stitching, developed <strong><a href="http://hermeskelly4cheap.com/Hermes-Birkin-Bag-Skyblue-Silver-42-CM-pid-... birkin blue</a></strong> in the 1800s, is another distinctive <strong><a href="http://hermeskelly4cheap.com/Hermes-Birkin-Bag-Orange-Golden-42-CM-pid-2... birkin orange</a></strong> feature.Each bag is hand-sewn, buffed, painted, and
polished, taking several days to finish. <a href="http://amazonhermesbirkin.com/Hermes-Kelly-Shoulder-Handbag-Pink-Silver-... Kelly Shoulder Handbag Pink Silver 32CM</a> An average bag is created in 48 hours. Leathers are obtained from different <strong><a href="hermesbirkin4discount.com/Hermes-Lindy-
Handbag-Blue-pid-2573.html">hermes birkin blue</a></strong> tanners in France, resulting in varying smells and textures. <strong><a href="http://hermesbirkinkellydiscount.com/Hermes-Birkin-Bag-Dark-Blue-Silver-... birkin blue</a></strong> Because of the individual craftsmanship, <strong><a href="hermesbirkinkellydiscount.com/Hermes-Birkin-Bag-Black-Silver-30CM-pid-2515.html">hermes birkin black</a></strong> other details of the bags may not all match. The <strong><a href="http://hermesbirkin4discount.com/Hermes-Kelly-Shoulder-Handbag-Orange-Si... birkin orange</a></strong> company justifies the cost of the Birkin bag, compared <strong><a href="http://hermesbirkin4cheap.com/Hermes-Bag-Black-tagid-61.html">hermes bags black</a></strong> to other bags, based on the meticulous craftsmanship and scarcity.<strong><a href="http://hermesbirkin4cheap.com/Hermes-Birkin-Bag-Blue-Silver-42-CM-pid-25... birkin blue</a></strong>

linmei800's picture
linmei800 - Feb 23, 2012

The bags <strong><a href="http://hermesbirkin4cheap.com/Hermes-Kelly-Shoulder-Handbag-Orange-Golde... birkin orange</a></strong> are handmade <strong><a href="http://hermesbirkin4cheap.com/Hermes-Birkin-HandBags-35CM-cid-422.html">... birkin 35</a></strong> in France by expert artisans. The company's <strong><a href="http://hermesbirkinkellydiscount.com/Hermes-Birkin-Bag-35CM-Orange-Silve... birkin orange</a></strong> signature saddle stitching, developed <strong><a href="http://hermeskelly4cheap.com/Hermes-Birkin-Bag-Skyblue-Silver-42-CM-pid-... birkin blue</a></strong> in the 1800s, is another distinctive <strong><a href="http://hermeskelly4cheap.com/Hermes-Birkin-Bag-Orange-Golden-42-CM-pid-2... birkin orange</a></strong> feature.Each bag is hand-sewn, buffed, painted, and
polished, taking several days to finish. <a href="http://amazonhermesbirkin.com/Hermes-Kelly-Shoulder-Handbag-Pink-Silver-... Kelly Shoulder Handbag Pink Silver 32CM</a> An average bag is created in 48 hours. Leathers are obtained from different <strong><a href="hermesbirkin4discount.com/Hermes-Lindy-
Handbag-Blue-pid-2573.html">hermes birkin blue</a></strong> tanners in France, resulting in varying smells and textures. <strong><a href="http://hermesbirkinkellydiscount.com/Hermes-Birkin-Bag-Dark-Blue-Silver-... birkin blue</a></strong> Because of the individual craftsmanship, <strong><a href="hermesbirkinkellydiscount.com/Hermes-Birkin-Bag-Black-Silver-30CM-pid-2515.html">hermes birkin black</a></strong> other details of the bags may not all match. The <strong><a href="http://hermesbirkin4discount.com/Hermes-Kelly-Shoulder-Handbag-Orange-Si... birkin orange</a></strong> company justifies the cost of the Birkin bag, compared <strong><a href="http://hermesbirkin4cheap.com/Hermes-Bag-Black-tagid-61.html">hermes bags black</a></strong> to other bags, based on the meticulous craftsmanship and scarcity.<strong><a href="http://hermesbirkin4cheap.com/Hermes-Birkin-Bag-Blue-Silver-42-CM-pid-25... birkin blue</a></strong>

SaminTexas's picture
SaminTexas - Jan 12, 2012

The gamesmanship regarding unemployment numbers is shocking. As Paul Krugman writes in his column, the strategy for repairing the economy thus far appears to be invoking the "confidence fairy." If the employment numbers improve, or the unemployment numbers are understated, we can con some of the less aware to start spending in the economy, which, by all accounts, seems to have happened slightly. However, this is a short-term effect, which will be followed by the "skepticism fairy" as participants find that there actually is no aggregate demand to support their increases in production. Economics has real consequences and is not merely a state of mind, contrary to what the Fed Chairman, Treasury Secretary, and Republicans think. Thank you Robert Reich for keeping it real.

KE's picture
KE - Jan 12, 2012

Reich's comment -
"If all these discouraged workers were included in the count, today's unemployment rate wouldn't be 8.5 percent. It would be 9.5 percent. That's only a bit down from the 9.9 percent unemployment rate two years ago." -
is very misleading because he added those workers to today's unemployment rate, but didn't add them to the previous unemployment rate. I assume he would give a poor grade to any of his students that provided such sloppy analysis.

Greg L's picture
Greg L - Jan 12, 2012

If you include those who “were not counted as unemployed because they had not searched for work in the 4 weeks preceding the survey; discouraged workers are a subset of the marginally attached,” you come up with a figure closer to 18% unemployment. Here’s a link to the math, complete with graphs and a full breakdown:

http://www.economicpopulist.org/content/whats-real-unemployment-rate

Personally, though, I don’t believe that any number should be a referendum on Barrack Obama’s presidency. In the first place, economic policies have not changed much from the neo-conservative policies that created the financial crisis; secondly, how much can one president be expected to do—alone—to change thirty years of failed supply-side policies and “innovative” financial machinations?

garydpdx's picture
garydpdx - Jan 11, 2012

Thanks to Robert Reich for pointing out how unemployed is defined. Too many people think that it's whether one is receiving unemployment benefits or not. When it's actually whether or not you are looking for work.

Also, I'm concerned about how recovery of the 8.5 Million jobs lost in the Great Recession is counted. When accounting for work force (population) growth, we have barely scratched break-even for the 30 months since the end of June 2009 when it ended. In that light, hardly any lost jobs have been recovered! :(

muzlin's picture
muzlin - Jan 11, 2012

So did you apply the discouraged worker adjustment to the 2 year old unemployment number before you compared it to the adjusted current number?