20

'This Space Available' and the problem with billboards

People sit in lounge chairs on Broadway in Times Square after it was converted to a pedestrian zone May 26, 2009 in New York City.

To view this content, Javascript must be enabled and Adobe Flash Player must be installed.

Get Adobe Flash player

Jeremy Hobson: Take a look around you today, and see how many billboards you can spot. You'll probably lose count pretty quick, because they are everywhere.

Well a new documentary that's premiering today at the Doc NYC Festival here in New York, explores just how fast billboard advertising has taken over public space.

It's called "This Space Available," and we're joined now by the director, Gwenaelle Gobe. Good morning.

Gwenaelle Gobe: Good morning, Jeremy.

Hobson: Well let's focus on the specifics. I drive by a famous building in Los Angeles all the time, it's on the corner of Wilshire and La Brea; it's an old building and it's got a big lit-up Samsung billboard on the top. What is wrong with that in principle?

Gobe: There's nothing wrong with buying and selling. But there is something wrong when wherever you go, whatever you do, you are treated as a consumer. There are places where that is appropriate, and there are places where that's not. There's a problem when students from a class don't recognize the trees that are in their neighborhoods, but if you show them an alphabet with just one letter picked out from logos, they will recognize every single brand.

Trailer from This space available on Vimeo.

Hobson: But it's not just billboards that are doing that obviously, that's something that's coming from television and from magazines and from images that they see all over the place. Why are billboards so much worse in your mind than the rest of the advertising we see?

Gobe: Because they're occupying a space that doesn't really belong to advertising; it belongs to everyone.

Hobson: Well let's talk about one of the most interesting parts of your film, which is Sao Paulo, Brazil, a place that has banned all billboard advertising.

Gobe: I think there was just too much of it, and it wasn't about who was making the best message or the best advertising. It was who was putting up the biggest billboard in the most places. There's a story of a bank billboard being bigger than the actual bank building. You couldn't see the city because it was covered in billboards. The mayor passed a law, and then everything was down in six months, which was pretty radical.

Jordan Seiler from This space available on Vimeo.

Hobson: Do you think that anything like that could ever happen here in the United States? In the advertising center of New York, for instance?

Gobe: I really do believe that it could happen, because it's not good for brands to be a pollution. I really believe in the passion of New Yorkers, and they love their city. I don't think they want it to look like any other city; I think they want it to look like New York.

Hobson: Gwenaelle Gobe, director of the new documentary film, "This Space Available." Thank you so much for joining us.

Gobe: Thank you Jeremy.

Pages

Ericka A's picture
Ericka A - Nov 8, 2011

Spain is another place that has banned billboards. They were worried that people were becoming distracted on the road, so they removed all of them. Now the only signs you see are the silloutte of the Spanish bull, which are still pretty few and far between. I think it not only helps by providing less of a distraction, but it also allows you to take in the true scenery.

Fred Price's picture
Fred Price - Nov 8, 2011

The State of Maine outlawed all billboards back in the 70's. That is one of the reasons why Maine is such a beautiful state to live in and travel through. This is not a new idea, but one that is fought vigorously by the owners of signs! Billboards are an intrusion on the individual rights of all citizens!

Barbara Broide's picture
Barbara Broide - Nov 8, 2011

While Laura Howard notes the potential life-saving uses for highway digital signs (used by Highway Patrol, FEMA, etc.) the sad fact is that those highway warning signs in California were nearly transformed into advertising messages by our former Governor who was desperate to raise funds to close the state's budget gap. When the signs are used for traffic messages, they tend to slow traffic (often rather suddenly). If they were to have been used for ads (glaring over the heads of drivers who are meant to be watching the road, not watching the ads), what would be the impact on safety? The digital sign technology is so new that there are no reliable studies to document the impacts on accident rates, etc. The prudent thing to do in all states is to STOP issuing permits for digital billboards until there has been adequate data gathered and analyzed to make certain that we are not endangering drivers, passengers, bikers, pedestrians... EVERYONE! Caution is needed. We just banned texting on phones to diminish driver distraction in California. Are we willing to exchange one form of distraction for another... why? One of our government's key responsibilities is to protect the public's safety and health. This is more than an aesthetic issue, more than an issue of personal preference (more than do you or I like or dislike the signs). It is a matter of public health and safety. Of course, it is also a test of our policymakers who often find campaign contributions from outdoor advertising companies (and the billboards that can be donated to candidates or their opponents)hard to resist.

Shawn Greene's picture
Shawn Greene - Nov 8, 2011

Vermont banned them in 1968! Now that is progressive. I hope to move there. I only wish my beautiful home state of North Carolina was as forward thinking.

Bonnie Marsh's picture
Bonnie Marsh - Nov 8, 2011

Four of our most scenic states, Maine, Vermont, Alaska, and Hawaii, have been without billboards for decades. It is such a visual relief to cross the border into Maine whenever I come home from a trip. That's the way life should be.

Ben Twining's picture
Ben Twining - Nov 8, 2011

You don't need to go to Brazil to find a community with billboards. Like Vermont, Maine has banned billboards along roads for many years.

Laura Howard's picture
Laura Howard - Nov 8, 2011

In some instances advertising does have a place, along highways and small boards directing people regarding what small business's are in their area. Large mass advertising does get truly invasive but it is not just billboards and to slam this media alone is misleading. Also, a new trend for digital boards is for states to align with Highway Patrol, FEMA, and Amber Alert to issue public safety warnings that can and will save lives.

Leticia Vega's picture
Leticia Vega - Nov 8, 2011

Residents in my community and around Miami Dade County, Florida are clear, we do not want these digital billboards , and gigantic ad “murals” polluting our visual fields and eroding our property values. The billboards are a form of visual pollution and make driving around South Florida less pleasant for residents and visitors alike. We need to ensure that the outdoor advertising industry does not continue to encroach on our way of life. In my investigations, I realized that the problem is pervasive through the US.

Alexander Maier's picture
Alexander Maier - Nov 8, 2011

In Sevierville, TN, there is even a sign at the city entrance, explaining that they banned billboards and apologizing for the defacement of the otherwise magnificent view (of the smoky mountains).

http://themountainpress.com/view/full_story/5896872/article--Dollywood-b...

Paul Furnas's picture
Paul Furnas - Nov 8, 2011

Please note that the state of Vermont banned billboards over 30 years ago. The effect is stunning; such a beautiful state.

Pages