7

Unemployment benefits vary greatly

A job seeker looks through job listings at the East Bay Works One-Stop Career Center in Oakland, Calif.

To view this content, Javascript must be enabled and Adobe Flash Player must be installed.

Get Adobe Flash player

Christine Vestal

TEXT OF INTERVIEW

Tess Vigeland: Of the millions of Americans who are out of work, you might be surprised to find out that not all of them are eligible for unemployment benefits. And depending on which state you live in, the benefits you do receive could be enough to tide you over. Or it could be a few bucks a week.

Christine Vestal is a writer covering unemployment for with the online news site Stateline.org. Chris, how different are the rules for unemployment benefits?

Christine Vestal: They vary for certain types of workers. If you're looking for a part-time job -- you could only work part-time or you've decided that that's the best thing for you and your family -- about half the states won't let you collect benefits. And that's not becaues you worked part-time, but because you're only seeking part-time work. So that's one issue. Another issue is if your work is sporatic, or if you just got your first job, or you'd been out for a while and then you got a job and you were laid off, they won't count the most recent earnings. So, lets say you got a job right out of college and it only lasted three, four months, you may not qualify because they want to look back farther than six months, typically.

Vigeland: But if you work, you're paying taxes toward unemployment benefits. So, how can you not be eligible for them if you lose your job?

Vestal: Well, that's what proponents of a new bill that's part of the stimulus package are saying: If you've worked and your employers contributed for you, you ought to be able to get the benefits. And this sort of technicality in the laws in many states is preventing an estimated 500,000 workers from getting benefits.

Vigeland: What about the amount of benefit? I was looking at some of these figures, and it's really dependant on where you are, you can get a huge variety on what your actual payout is on unemployment.

Vestal: That's right. It varies at the low end and the high end. Hawaii has the lowest weekly check, $5.

Vigeland: $5.

Vestal: $5 a week. But, at the same time, you only need to have made $130 in the previous year to qualify. So that salary at which you can then receive benefits is different in different states. North Carolina, the minimum salary that you can make for a year and qualify is $4,113. That's the highest.

Vigeland: And what about the benefits themselves? Who's the best, who's the worst?

Vestal: At the low end, the minimum benefit, Hawaii has the lowest at $5 per week. At the high end, for the minimum benefit for a low-wage worker, Oregon has the best at $104 per week. Now, if you make more than, say $40,000, and it varies from state to state, Mississippi has the lowest maximum benefit. Nobody in Mississippi collecting benefits can make more than $210 per week. But Massachusettes has the highest by far, at $862 per week.

Vigeland: So is there anything that folks can do if they're either fearing a layoff or have just been laid off, to know right away what their benefits are going to be? How they're eligible?

Vestal: Well, you can check the website for either the state you work in or the state you live in.

Vigeland: Either one?

Vestal: Either one.

Vigeland: So you can go unemployment and insurance shopping?

Vestal: You can and you should. You really should. Some regions where there are a lot of people living in one state and working in another state, you know, have tried to smooth out the minimum and the maximum. But other regions, there are great differences.

Vigeland: So, do your research.

Vestal: Do your research. Yes.

Vigeland: Good advice. Christine Vestal is a staff writer for Stateline.org, a project of the Pew Center on the states. Thanks so much.

Vestal: Thank you, Tess.

About the author

Tess Vigeland is the host of Marketplace Money, where she takes a deep dive into why we do what we do with our money. Follow Tess on Twitter @radiotess
dave hegarty's picture
dave hegarty - Feb 19, 2009

The Massachusetts benefit of $900/wk includes the maximum benefit from the Medical Security Plan ($1080 a month for a family plan) So, yes the maximum 628 regular benefit + 270 (1080/4 weeks per month) is $900/week

Kathryn Lansink's picture
Kathryn Lansink - Feb 11, 2009

I didn't realize I was eligible to "shop around" for benefits until I filed a claim yesterday. The very helpful employee ran my numbers in both AZ & CO and I will get $475 in CO vs. $240 had I filed in AZ.

Ryan Schmid's picture
Ryan Schmid - Feb 8, 2009

Unemployment insurance is ultimately paid for by employees through lower wages - similar to the social security tax.... I think both are valid programs however and I am glad that both exist.

gregory loring's picture
gregory loring - Feb 8, 2009

the gentleman from Damariscotta is wrong I worked in New Jersey and unemployment insurance tax was taken directly from my paycheck. As in other states it was not.

Linda Mitchell's picture
Linda Mitchell - Feb 8, 2009

As a residential alien I finished a set-term work contract in September 2008 abroad. I returned to the US and my husband and I have not been eligible for any benefits other than heating oil. So we have been without an income for over 4 months. We live in a rural area with no jobs. It is not through lack of trying that we are in this position. So just be aware of this factor as well.

Randall Peterson's picture
Randall Peterson - Feb 8, 2009

Ms. Vigeland's statement, "But if you work, you're paying taxes toward unemployment benefits." is not accurate. Employees do not pay taxes toward unemployment benefits. The employer pays a tax based on the total payroll of all employees. The tax is not in any way passed on to the employee as a deduction from the employee's gross wages. Unemployment taxes are a cost of doing business that the employer bears.

Mass Guy's picture
Mass Guy - Feb 7, 2009

You said "Massachusettes has the highest by far, at $862 per week." That is incorrect, it is $628 per week.