3

Sometimes 'payday' rhymes with 'mayday'

Mayday, as in the international distress signal. It is from the French "M'Aider!" or "Help Me!" Payday, as in so-called payday loans, where a loan shop around the corner will float money at a high interest rate until the paycheck shows up and the borrower can pay off short term loan.

The payday loan industry believes it is providing a valuable service, but many see payday loans as exploitative. Even the U.S. Department of Defense looked into whether our national security suffers if troops get dangerously distracted if families get too into hock to payday loan companies. This resulted in new rules for the rates and fees a payday loan company can charge servicemen and women. At the time, a senior Pentagon official said "We equate financial readiness with mission readiness."

With that in mind, consider the dire warning issued by a George Mason University professor of law. Professor Todd Zywicki's argument, which appeared in a column in the opinion page of the Wall Street Journal this week, suggests that the financial reform law passed last summer will drive people into the hands of payday loan firm. Pawnshops, too.

The idea is, by cracking down on the credit card industry and regulating fees and terms, the Dodd-Frank law could make it extremely tough for people with high credit risk. But, people have to borrow money from somewhere. If their car's transmission goes, which is one example the professor cites, then they will likely turn to the sharks, is the idea.

What do you think of this argument? I am all ears.

About the author

David Brancaccio is the host of Marketplace Tech Report. Follow David on Twitter @DavidBrancaccio and @MarketplaceTech
susangreen's picture
susangreen - Oct 9, 2012

I have payday loans and cant get away and before you all stay I shouldn't have got 1, my car failed its mot I work 20 miles away and its 4 buses to work so got a payday loan as a last resort, but I tried every thing and they is nothing else in place to help people in a tight spot, if I was on benefits I could have got a crisis loan why doesn't government do state loans for low income and take money every month out of wage it would stop all this.
http://northenloans.ca/

paydaylendingrep's picture
paydaylendingrep - Jan 11, 2011

The argument that payday lenders exploit people is not valid. The payday loan industry does not exploit anyone, but provides valuable service, the much needed short-term credit which many banks either do not provide or refuse to provide to the customers who do not meet their stringent guidelines. The payday advance industry exists because it offers customers a product that is more desirable than other financial alternatives.

Belinda's picture
Belinda - Jan 13, 2011

Payday advances play a necessary role, providing hard-working people with a reasonable, well-regulated option for meeting unexpected or unbudgeted expenses and other short-term financial needs. The payday advance industry exists because we offer our customers a product that is more desirable than the alternatives.
Adults should be given information and be allowed to make a decision about what financial products work best for their families and their individual situations.