5
Amid hope, black homeowners struggle
Commentator Amelia Tyagi
To view this content, Javascript must be enabled and Adobe Flash Player must be installed.
TEXT OF COMMENTARY
KAI RYSSDAL: The speech President Obama gave today was, in part, pretty sobering, coming as it did in the middle of the worst economic crisis in decades.
At the same time there was a can-do attitude about it. Mixed feelings might also be the order of the day for a lot of African Americans. Today's a historic milestone.
But commentator Amelia Tyagi says the economy's creating milestones of a different sort.
AMELIA TYAGI: Perhaps 2009 will be remembered as the most ironic year in African American history. On the one hand, we have our first African American president, a milestone of unprecedented importance.
And yet, 2009 may also go down in history as the year that more African Americans fell out of the middle class than any other time in our nation's past. Best estimates are that African American homeowners are 2-1/2 times more likely to be in foreclosure than their white counterparts. At that rate, more than a million African American homeowners will lose their home in the next four years. That's one in every five.
Why is the trouble so much worse for African Americans? Because they were specifically targeted by banks peddling dangerous subprime mortgages. When people applied for home mortgages, blacks were far more likely than whites to receive the high-cost loans.
And this isn't just about credit scores and other assets. In fact, residents in high-income African American neighborhoods are now more likely to have a subprime mortgage than residents in low-income white neighborhoods.
Brandon Ethridge is a law student from a largely African American middle-class neighborhood outside Baltimore. He described a family on his block, two professionals who "came home from work one day and the lights had been turned out. A bank official was outside. They had to move their stuff out in the middle of the night."
By the time a family loses their home, they have drained their bank account, ruined their credit score, and cashed out their retirement savings, all in a desperate attempt to save the home. For many, this is the end of the American dream.
Many in Brandon's neighborhood are first-generation homeowners, victors in a hard-fought battle to climb up the economic ladder. In the swirl of the subprime crisis, African American homeownership rates are poised to lose an entire generation of progress in a few short years.
Brandon remarked, "No one thinks about this as a civil rights issue."
But maybe we should.
RYSSDAL: Amelia Warren Tyagi is co-founder of Business Talent Group.
The listener comments are very telling about how strong the ideology of neoliberalism is in the US. Of course oversight and sanctions are needed, otherwise businesses will continue to exploit workers and consumers. It's too bad most people aren't aware of what unregulated America really looked like in the 19th century.
Lack of personal responsibilities and accountability, and lack of personal financial education, combined with unprecedented level of greed has created this negative confluence of historical proportion we are witnessing globally today. People without adequate understanding of legal ramifications of their own actions, be they may black Americans or white Bulgarians, have suffered significantly when wealth built upon illusion evaporated like mirage. The idea of creating a 'civil rights' issue out of this is not only absurd, it also does disservice to blacks by giving them an easy way out instead of learning from our own mistakes, like all of us should.
I usually enjoy the parts on this program but this one really irritated me. It seems like everyone, black or white seem to try to blame others for their problems. It is one thing to lose your job because a company was mismanaged or perhaps you can not get a loan from a bank now, but to blame "The Banks" for getting you into a home you couldn't afford or a loan that didn't make sense is ridiculous. It seems all to common in this country to blame others when we make mistakes and this story just proved yet again that until people change there ways the country will continue to go down hill.
Wow, Kai, why ON EARTH was this broadcast? I found this commentary Incredibly insulting.
The point seems to be: "African Americans" cannot be trusted to handle personal liberty. Since the objectionable actions were, in nearly all cases, legal & legit contracts between consenting adults - Ms. Tyagi implies "African Americans" need some kind of wiser overseer to monitor and regulate their private lives and contracts. That's exactly what John C. Calhoun thought -- and Ms. Tyagi is wrong for the same reasons.
