The trouble with refinancing a student loan

Are you drowning in student loan debt?

It doesn’t seem fair, right? The U.S. Treasury gets to borrow money at about 2 percent interest these days. That’s latest yield on the 10-year Treasury note. When the government turns around and loans that money to college students, most of them are paying well over 6 percent interest. Meanwhile, the average fixed rate on a 30-year mortgage these days is just over 3.5 percent.

To understand why student borrowers pay so much more, I started with my go-to guy for all things financial aid, Mark Kantrowitz of FinAid.org. He says there are two big reasons federal student loans cost more than, say, a mortgage or car loan. Nobody checks your credit. And there’s no collateral.

“If you default on a federal education loan, they can’t repossess your education,” he says.

Other kinds of unsecured debt -- like credit cards -- usually cost much more, he says. “For someone with a typical credit pattern of a college graduate, we’re talking a 10, 11 percentage interest rate -- maybe even as high as 14 percent.”

Even at comparatively low rates, more people are defaulting on their education loans. And unlike other types of debt, you can’t escape student loans by filing for bankruptcy.

One youth advocacy group is pitching an idea to make it easier to pay them off -- a federal loan refinancing program.

“If you refinance loans down to 5 percent -- so just the loans that are above that -- that would save people about $14 billion in interest rate payments for this year alone,” says Tobin Van Ostern, deputy director of Campus Progress. It's part of the liberal Center for American Progress.

“It would be huge,” says Jennifer Belmont Jennings, an attorney in St. Louis. “For us, personally, it would just add a significant level of security to us.”

Belmont Jennings finished law school just as high-paying legal jobs seemed to evaporate. She owes about $170,000 in student loans, and says she could really use a few hundred extra dollars a month.

“Just from a spending standpoint of being able to do things, you know,” she says. “We bought a house several years later than we would have had we had that extra money.”

When they did buy a house, this year, they got a mortgage rate of 3.7 percent.

It is possible to refinance student loans -- privately. SoFi makes loans to students and graduates of certain colleges. The loans are funded by alumni of those schools. For a re-fi CEO Mike Cagney says the average borrower comes in with a rate of about 7.2 percent.

“We’re refinancing them into rates between 6 and 6.5,” he says. “And the borrower’s savings have been about $10,000 over the life of the loan.”

But to qualify you have to have gone to one of the 79 schools SoFi works with, like Carnegie Mellon or the University of Michigan. To refinance on a large scale, Cagney says, the federal government would need to step in.

About the author

Amy Scott is Marketplace’s education correspondent covering the K-12 and higher education beats, as well as general business and economic stories.
Log in to post23 Comments


ACT tutoring Chapel Hill--If you are searching an expert ACT tutoring Chapel Hill? We are the best institute who can prepare you for the ACT, SAT and for the other tests in the schools and organizations.For more information please visit: http://www.mindspireprep.com/

1. Your student loan reduction measure failed consequently interest rates will increase. Lots of individuals include give up seeking to pay back their own loans simply because cannot afford to cover them and give them selves as well. It will take nearly ninety days to have it arrive over a credit profile and a few are usually getting mothers and fathers along with them on their Mum or dad Plus loans. Minimal and behold Parents, Cousin or perhaps Older brother cannot genuinely assist you both. Bypassing installments on one insert to make additional installments is not going to operate both.

only two. Simply because there is a more complex stage with all the current suitable accreditation will not imply business people requested for will hire people - these are getting more ORIGINATE international personnel compared to People in the usa. Even Showmanship does this particular. The reason why hire an National when you can hire an individual that's pleased regarding fifty percent this pay and no positive aspects? Setup needs impossibly excessive, next complain it's not possible to locate a competent "American" for the work. Have you thought to start a account about this? There's a good supply inside Amnesty invoice to allow more international personnel (currently forty two. 8 THOUSAND are usually the following now) to the US.

3. Obvious trolling is suffocating advancement and new technology. I hold hunting by way of patent app operations and have absolutely observed I can not afford the $15, 000 + expected just for a new provisional patent! Nevertheless I could truthfully end up being sued regarding thousands by simply an individual whom will not carry a program to sell whom keeps a new patent consequently largely identified it could be interpreted for almost anything.

5. Individuals who cannot find work include go to this military divisions! Just try to get a employer for you to telephone people again in a month, in no way mind a week. They've are more fastidious with regards to completely new utilizes because they are a great number of for you to selected from now.

5. Simply no rules in any respect on which interest rates banking institutions may charge. I've truly noticed college students kicked out there by simply their own mothers and fathers taking on loans along with curiosity of up to 27%! College students don't have a option with loans because possibly survival (including Interpersonal Protection and Disability) could be garnished to purchase these types of loans. College students don't have a privileges both. Many people pay up or perhaps get their credit history demolished even though they are functioning a couple of bare minimum income work to take and hold a new top around their own mind. Quite a few individual creditors tend not to deliver deferment, fee interest rates in 8% or maybe more as the university student is enrolled in college, and no extended defer settlement (used to be half a year with a year) even though this university student does not have any profits.


6. Stress induced health conditions. Thought credit debt has been awful? Why not consider owed 100K and discovering that your livelihood has been shipped overseas where by you aren't pleasant and the work markets are usually more complicated than the US? Prepare for your quality of life to adopt a new nose jump functioning those odd, unsafe work offering simply no medical health insurance. Ones salary will be way too smaller to cover every little thing consequently get used to becoming more serious away compared to you were before going for you to college.

7. Simply no investment throughout schooling. Funding regarding higher education could have cut the head away this particular creature however, many simpleton chose men and women on this land are just the following for you to bail out there banking institutions and get them to loaded. I settled increased tax regarding CEOs yet attach the people would you basically produce work on this land in the event the prospect wasn't taken from their website by the loaded survival organisms on this land.

8. Scholarships, scholarships and "financial aid" are only for the very bad, unlawful immigrants or perhaps this minorities. For anyone who is merely bad, white or even cheaper center class you will get NOT ANY school funding, scholarships or perhaps get scholarship grants. I noticed nothing but racist scholarship grants declaring this customer wouldn't normally be regarded except this had been black or perhaps hispanic - or perhaps of which inclination could be proven to of which epidermis color/ethnicity. There have been simply no MERIT-Based scholarship grants at the universities I transferred in to and out of. NO. Your school funding he constrained with with regards to is nonexistent. Exactly what college has been he talking about? I have no idea of a person with merely 20K throughout student loan debts except they will don't finish making their own stage. Quite a few don't have a decision yet to figure and so the youngsters of the loaded have already yet another knee up on them. The length of time is it possible to operate 25 hrs a week and perform 62 hours connected with class help simply no nights away?

9. Constrained or perhaps nonexistent payment choices. You possibly can pay for a price it's not possible to afford at the moment while you don't have a work OR PERHAPS you possibly can pay for a much higher fee that will keep people destitute. Loan companies likewise hold ratcheting up curiosity with loans concise it becomes impossible to repay. In the end this university student will give up paying. Men and women could merely take a great deal problems previous to they've already experienced enough and a few are going to a bankruptcy proceeding court docket ready to verify they shall be destitute because they cannot locate a work that will equally give them and the money grubbing creditors.

10. Missing wages/earnings/investments from these types of college students caused by predatory creditors will injure this economic system even worse compared to unlawful immigration and international personnel. Cash siphoned off of a new consumerist economic system by simply those transmitting funds out of your land the ones whom aren't keeping it is going to injure getting energy overall in the usa. If younger cannot afford a property and rental prices their complete life he can include small equity or perhaps world wide web worth to demonstrate for this. Simply no completely new or perhaps car or truck, simply no kids, simply no retirement life home egg which means this survival software programs we have now stretched will be drowning in the red.

Whenever they had been to actually take the time choosing these types of college students they might find an unsightly reality. School degrees in the usa aren't worthwhile. Organisations wish temp staff members, contract merely, simply no positive aspects, simply no overtime pay, and also constrained privileges. Rob Perry is getting companies in to the future for you to Arizona simply because wages the following happen to be stressed out by simply unlawful immigrants and international personnel. Don't think us? We've locations where by no person speaks Language and 24% (too low several in my opinion) connected with personnel are usually uninsured. Welfare charges are usually rising for you to unsustainable prices and no one wishes to declare this is actually the future bubble for you to rush. Your riots in the usa is likely to make those throughout European countries seem like a new cakewalk if the Screwed Age group usually takes things into their individual fingers.

11. Educational institutions tend not to help college students with work searching, getting companies, or even expose this RETURN their own stage will afford them.
This is by simply and significantly one of the biggest complaints other than simply no school funding. You possibly can create a foolish style analyze yet whenever searching for of which elementary work you will be by yourself. You'd feel a new college would like to boast with regards to their own university student hire fee yet the truth is these are at this time there only reserved for your current mortgage loan funds. There isn't any charge regarding creating more people who will be depending on survival on this land.

In essence of which US companies wish cost-free toil from experienced staff members without any cost cost. This system cannot last much longer.

This story has one HUGE FALSEHOOD. BY LAW, your federal student loan aid from the govt. can't have an interest rate larger than 7%, and the rate goes up and down with the Federal Reserve rate. When you consolidate your loans with the feds, you get a set rate for life that no longer goes up or down-- mine is 3.5%. The only way the rate is ever higher than 7% is from a private loan lender, NOT THE GOVT. You staff needs to correct this falsehood right away.

That is incorrect. When you consolidate your loans with the feds, you get a weighted average rate of the loans being consolidated. For people who entered college before the recession, their rates were around 8%. When I consolidated and went on IBR, my new rate was a whopping 7%. Consolidation saved me a whole .5%. To be clear, I had absolutely NO private loans. The worst part is that on IBR, my payments dont even cover the interest and my unpaid interest gets capitalized annually into the principle. So not only am I not paying my loans down, I'm actually growing the principle by making payments. Moreover, at the end of my loan (in 25 years) I'll get hit with taxable income for the amount that is forgiven, likely pushing me into a higher tax bracket and giving me "phantom" income that I'll be taxed on. Meanwhile...banks borrow at .75% rates, automobile financing can be had for 4% and home loans are 3.75%...all I did was try to improve my lot in life, foolish me.

That part about the interest rate isn't true. When I borrowed in the 1990s, the interest rate for federally guaranteed student loans was 8% for the first two years and 10% after that. Most people consolidated their loans early in the loan period to keep the interest rate at 8%. As a result, when interest rates dropped, we were unable to consolidate/refinance again because the law says you can only do so once.


With Generous Support From...