Ask Money - Most Commented


smpls picture

Question: Use HSA or pay out of pocket?

Submitted by smpls | Aug 05,2012

I moved to my companies high deductible plan this year. I typically have very few medical expenses and this was also a great way to add to my retirement as I already max out my 401k contributions and I also maxed out my HSA contributions. I am in a position that I can pay my expenses without going into my HSA or other savings. I already have 9 months living expenses in a saving account, so this would not take away from money that would go to my safety net.

If I am considering my HSA as a way to save for retirement, it seems to me I would want to minimize withdraws and let the amount accumulate into retirement.

Do I pay with the HSA withdrawing money from a tax deferred account to pay the bills and invest the money not used in another investment?

Or do I pay out of pocket and leave the money where it is safely tucked away for major medical expense or retirement?

tmaddentm picture

Question: How to Semi-Retire Early

Submitted by tmaddentm | Aug 13,2012

My husband and I are striving to "semi-retire" in about 10 years at the age of 40, where both of us will drop to working part time (20 hrs a week) until age 65.

We have a "rainy day" fund of about $28,000, and currently feel very secure with our 401(k) and Roth IRA savings plans, but we don't want to take the penalty that goes along with withdrawing these funds before age of 59-1/2 years old.

We are now trying to figure out the best place to save the money that we will need to live between age 40 and age 65. The options we have considered so far are a money market account, investing in index funds or a "safe" mix of mutual funds and stocks. What is the best way to save/grow our money?

Thank you for your advice!

sauer148 picture

Question: New college grad: How to save my money?

Submitted by sauer148 | Apr 23,2013

I'm graduating with a BS in Chemical Engineering this year. I have a job lined up in the Twin Cities, MN where I will be working for a company I love and finally making money to pay off student loans (salary ~$55,000/yr before taxes). My question to you is: how should I be handling my money while working?

I will be renting for a few years before (hopefully) having enough saved up to put a down payment on a home. Realistically, what portion of my salary is appropriate to spend on living during these few years, and how much should I be saving for my home down payment?

How quickly should I be paying off student loans? Is this an area that should take priority over others?

How much money should I then be putting away? Retirement plans, investments, emergency funds, etc. How much should I try to save for "fun" things? A new road bike, baseball games, travel, etc.

Are there other areas that I'm also completely neglecting when considering this? I haven't had much experience with finances, and I'm really looking for all the help I can get! Any advice would be great. Bear in mind, I grew up a farm boy, so luxury/expensive hobbies/etc. are not a part of my background. I would just like to live comfortably and plan appropriately for the future.

Let me know what you think and if there's any advice you have for a guy finally getting out into the real world. Thanks!

caceccs picture

Question: Cancel your 401(k)?

Submitted by caceccs | Aug 14,2012

Is it possible to cancel my 401(k) without showing hardship?

Listener questions on saving, spending, and managing debt

Sep 21, 2012
Host Tess Vigeland and Jill Schlesinger, editor at large for CBS's, answers listener questions about retirement, savings, students loans, and money management.
Posted In: student debt, Saving, real estate, Retirement, Investing, debt

Heading towards fiscal health

Aug 31, 2012
David Lazarus of the Los Angeles Times answers caller questions on personal finance, along with CBS editor-at-large Jill Schlesinger.
Posted In: family, marriage, Social Security, identity theft, Retirement, emergency fund, college

Financial planning for baby

Aug 24, 2012
There's a lot to decide before you have a baby. Certified financial planner Louis Barajas answers expecting parents' questions about how to be prepared financially for your baby.
Posted In: pregnancy, louis barajas, callers, questions

Letters: An estate planning primer

Jul 13, 2012
This week's letter segments tackles questions for the senior set.
Posted In: letters, Estate planning, death, 401(k), Savings

Letters: Solving problems with the plastic

Jul 6, 2012
Credit cards can make you feel like anything's possible -- until you get the bill.
Posted In: letters, credit card debt, liz weston

Emergency fund in retirement

Jun 29, 2012
Your most recent program discussed the amount and kind of emergency funds needed for people working. My question is what those of us who are retired should consider for emergency funds. William, Schenectady, NY
Posted In: emergency savings, Savings, Retirement, retirement spending


About this collection

Want to talk personal finances? Ask or answer questions in the Marketplace Money question-answer forum.